Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Focus Forward · Relationships

What to Do When the Next Generation Isn’t Ready, or Doesn’t Want, to Take Over: Two Different Problems, and Why Owners Keep Solving the Wrong One

“Can’t yet” and “won’t ever” look almost identical from the outside, call for opposite responses, and treating one as the other is how families lose both the company and the relationship.

Last updated: August 13, 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MHRLR, SPHR, Focus Forward Coaching, Milford Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer

Readiness and willingness are two different problems, and almost every owner I meet is trying to solve the wrong one. A successor who is not ready has a capability gap: it is measurable, it closes on a timeline, and the research says the single most reliable thing that closes it is real work somewhere other than your company. A successor who does not want the job does not have a gap. They have an answer. No development plan fixes it, and pressure makes the eventual outcome worse, not better. So diagnose first, honestly, and then act: build the one, or stop building and choose among the real alternatives; an outside CEO, promoting a long-tenured non-family leader, an ESOP, a sale to a third party, or holding ownership and hiring someone to run it. Every one of those alternatives asks you for the same thing your family conversation has been avoiding: a person other than you who can run this company.

First, What Are You Actually Measuring?

There is no license, no exam and no governing body for “successor readiness.” Worth saying plainly, because it means the assessment is a judgment call. And judgment calls made by a parent about a child are the least reliable judgment calls in business. So define the two things separately before you assess either.

Readiness is capability plus credibility. Can this person run a P&L, hire and fire, hold a peer accountable, read a balance sheet, and be followed by people who did not attend their high school graduation? It is observable, and other people can score it.

Willingness is whether they want the job. It sounds soft. It is not, and the research on it is more precise than most owners expect.

Pramodita Sharma and P. Gregory Irving, writing in Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice in 2005, argued that successor commitment had been treated as one thing when it is actually four. They proposed “four bases of successor commitment to family firm—affective (based on perceived desire), normative (based on perceived sense of obligation), calculative (based on perceived opportunity costs involved), and imperative (based on perceived need).”

Read those four again with your own successor in mind. Three of them will keep a person in the building. Only one of them is wanting the job.

A later study by Alexandra Dawson, Sharma, Irving, Joel Marcus and Francesco Chirico, in the same journal in 2013, tested this across 199 family firms; 78 Canadian and 121 Swiss. Desire-based and obligation-based commitment were both significant positive predictors of a next-generation member’s intention to stay, with the desire-based form showing the strongest relationship to favorable outcomes. The cost-based form, staying because leaving would be expensive, showed the weakest relationship and was not statistically significant.

That is the whole diagnostic problem in one finding. Obligation will hold your son in the chair. It will not make him good at it, and it will not make him stay for the reason you want.

How Do You Tell the Two Apart?

What you are looking at Not ready yet Doesn’t want it
What they say when asked directly “I need more time with the operations side” “I’ll do it if I have to”, or changes the subject
Response to more authority Takes it, then asks a lot of questions Takes it, then quietly gives pieces of it back
What they ask you about How something works, why a decision was made When you are retiring, what the business is worth
Behavior on the worst day of the quarter Present, out of their depth, still there at 7pm Unreachable, or technically present
Outside offers Turns them down and tells you about it Does not mention them
Timeline Closes in 18 months to 5 years with a real plan Does not close. It is not a gap
What it costs to misread it You hand over too early and they get hurt in public You spend six years developing someone who was always going to leave

None of these rows is proof on its own. The pattern is the diagnosis, and the fastest way to get it wrong is to ask the question in a way that only has one acceptable answer.

Here is the part that complicates it, and you should know it before you go looking for a clean line between the two. Marylène Gagné, Connor Marwick, Stéphanie Brun de Pontet and Carsten Wrosch followed 89 Canadian family businesses for twelve years and published the results in Family Business Review in 2021. Their finding: “successors’ confidence and perceptions of incumbent support predicted successor intrinsic motivation to take over the business, which in turn predicted whether the business was successfully transferred 12 years later.”

Confidence and felt support predicted wanting it. Wanting it predicted whether the handover actually happened, more than a decade later.

So readiness and willingness are separate problems that feed each other. A successor who has never been trusted with anything real will read as unwilling, because in a meaningful sense they have been trained to be. Before you conclude that your daughter does not want this, be able to name the last thing you let her own without commentary. If you cannot, you have not diagnosed anything yet.

If They Can, But Not Yet: What Actually Closes the Gap

The evidence on this is unusually specific, and it points somewhere most owners find annoying.

Send them away first. A working paper by Irena Kustec, Charlotte Ostergaard and Amir Sasson, circulated by the European Corporate Governance Institute in December 2020, examined 2,579 family-controlled Norwegian firms that changed CEO between 2005 and 2011. Their finding: “this underperformance is entirely driven by family successors who are recruited from within the firm and find that two-thirds of such successors do not have outside work experience. Family successors with outside work experience, however, perform on par with professional CEOs.”

Entirely driven. Not partly. The gap between a family successor and a hired professional, in that data, closes when the family successor has worked somewhere else first and two-thirds of the internal ones never had. This is also why the published family employment policies put a number on outside experience before anyone applies; I go through how to write that rule, and apply it to everyone, in How to Bring a Spouse, Sibling, or In-Law Into the Business Fairly.

Give them one whole thing, with a number on it. A division, a function, a location, a P&L they own for at least a year. Not a project. Something with a result that is theirs whether it goes well or badly.

Write the standard down before you assess anyone against it. What does “ready” mean here, in what areas, judged by whom, by when? If the standard exists only in your head, your successor is being graded on a test they cannot see, and everyone in the building knows it.

Let somebody other than you do the assessing. A board, an outside advisor, a peer group, a non-family executive whose judgment you trust. The relationship between a founder and their child does not produce a clean performance review, and pretending otherwise wastes years.

The cost of skipping all this is documented. Francisco Pérez-González, in the American Economic Review in 2006, found that firms where incoming CEOs were related to the departing CEO, a founder or a large shareholder “underperform in terms of operating profitability and market-to-book ratios, relative to firms that promote unrelated CEOs,” and that “lower performance is prominent in firms that appoint family CEOs who did not attend selective undergraduate institutions.” Morten Bennedsen, Kasper Meisner Nielsen, Pérez-González and Daniel Wolfenzon, using Danish data in the Quarterly Journal of Economics in 2007, put a causal number on it: “operating profitability on assets falls by at least four percentage points around CEO transitions” when the successor is family.

Those studies do not describe your child. What they do tell you is that “we’ll promote them and they’ll grow into it” is the most expensive sentence in this whole subject, and that the fix is probably not more time inside your company. It is time outside it.

One problem sits right next to this one and is not what this article is about: whether you can actually stop making the decisions once you have handed them over. A successor who looks unready is sometimes a successor who has never been allowed to be ready, and that is a different diagnosis with a different fix. I have written about it separately in When the Founder Can’t Let Go: Helping an Owner Step Back From Control.

If They Don’t Want It: How to Have the Conversation Without Wrecking the Relationship

Assume for a moment you have diagnosed it correctly and the answer is no. The conversation is survivable, and the way people wreck it is predictable.

  • Ask before you offer. Once you have said “I want you to take over,” every subsequent answer is a response to your hope rather than a report on their life. Ask what they want their working life to look like in ten years, and do not mention the company in the same sentence.
  • Assume they already know what you want. Writing for IMD in 2014, Denise Kenyon-Rouvinez and Anne-Catrin Glemser note that parents often avoid this conversation precisely because they are afraid of applying pressure — and that avoiding it does not work, because children pick up on their parents’ expectations whether or not those expectations are ever spoken. Your silence is not neutral. It has been read for years.
  • Separate the job from the shares, out loud, in the first sentence. “Not running it” and “not owning any of it” are different decisions, and if your child thinks declining the job means declining the family, they will say yes and mean no. Say which one you are asking about. How the ownership half then gets divided is a separate decision with its own piece: Fair vs. Equal: Dividing Ownership and Roles Among Your Children.
  • Do not make it a referendum on gratitude. The moment the conversation becomes about what you sacrificed, you will get a yes, and it will be the obligation-based commitment the research says is a poor foundation for anything except staying.
  • Give them a version of the story they can tell. Most adult children who decline are not declining the business. They are declining being the person who ended it. Build the alternative plan first, then have the conversation, so what they are saying no to is a job, not the company’s survival.
  • Write down what you heard, and set a real date to revisit it. Twelve or eighteen months, on the calendar, with the explicit understanding that “no” now is allowed to stay “no.” A door that is genuinely open gets walked through more often than one that is being held open pointedly.

What Are the Real Alternatives?

Start with what actually happens, because the room you are in is more crowded than it feels. Gallup surveyed 1,264 US owners whose work is primarily their own business, between September 20 and October 28, 2024. The breakdown: “Only 26% plan to give it away to a family member or someone else, and 23% plan to sell, with an additional 2% hoping to take the business public.” Another 22% “plan on closing the business,” and “a third of all business owners say they have no plan or are unsure about their future.”

A third have no plan. You are not unusual. You are earlier in the conversation than you would like to be.

Route What it requires that you may not have Where it usually breaks
Hire an outside CEO A board or owner group willing to hold a non-family executive accountable, and a written scope of decisions that are genuinely theirs The owner stays in the building as an unofficial appeal court, and the CEO leaves inside two years
Promote a long-tenured non-family leader Someone already there who can be given the seat, plus a retention package and a clear answer for the family members they now outrank Nobody told the family, or the promotion carries the title without the authority
ESOP 15–20 employees minimum, sustained profitability, and, per NCEO, “capable successor management must be in place” if the seller is the key manager Owners reach for it as an answer to “there’s nobody to run it,” which is precisely the condition it does not solve
Sale to a third party A management team that survives your departure, clean books, and a realistic view of what an owner-dependent business is worth The buyer discounts for exactly the gap that started this whole article
Hold and hire Willingness to become an owner rather than an operator, and a real governance structure to replace the decisions you used to make in the hallway It becomes a permanent delay rather than a stage, and nothing is ever decided
Staged handover A written sequence with dates, a defined assessment point, and a named off-ramp if the successor is wrong for the seat No date is ever set, so “staged” becomes “someday”

Two of those deserve numbers rather than adjectives.

On the ESOP. The National Center for Employee Ownership, working from Department of Labor Form 5500 filings, identified 6,609 ESOPs in the United States covering 15.1 million participants and holding over $2 trillion in plan assets; 5,993 of the sponsoring companies are privately held. This is a real route, not a curiosity, and NCEO states that “an ESOP can buy a departing owner’s shares in pretax dollars on terms that are favorable to the owner, the employees, and the business itself.” The costs are serious, though “most leveraged ESOPs will probably cost $150,000 to $400,000 to set up and run the first year and, for most companies with fewer than a few hundred employees, $20,000 to $30,000 annually” and NCEO’s guidance sets a floor of 15 to 20 employees and warns that “if you do not have enough profit to pay for that and operate your business, an ESOP will not work.”

On the outside CEO. Christina Wing and Rohit K. Gera wrote in Harvard Business Review in October 2023 that “most multigenerational family businesses eventually arrive at the same decision point: the current generation realizes it needs to hire a non-family-member to run the business.” Eventually, which is a polite way of saying most families get there late, after the internal option has been tried twice.

The Part Most People Miss: Every One of These Exits Prices the Same Missing Person

Most articles on this topic end where the table above ends: if the kids don’t want it, hire someone or sell it. True, and not very useful to you, because it quietly assumes the hard part is choosing between the options. It isn’t. The hard part is that all of the options ask the same question, and it is the question you have been avoiding at the dinner table.

The IRS has been saying so since 1959. Revenue Ruling 59-60 was issued, in its own words, “to outline and review in general the approach, methods and factors to be considered in valuing shares of the capital stock of closely held corporations for estate tax and gift tax purposes.” Among the factors it lists, Section 4.02(b) includes this:

“The loss of the manager of a so-called ‘one-man’ business may have a depressing effect upon the value of the stock of such business, particularly if there is a lack of trained personnel capable of succeeding to the management of the enterprise.”

That sentence is sixty-seven years old and it is describing your Tuesday. Not a family dynamic — a valuation adjustment. The absence of “trained personnel capable of succeeding to the management” is a documented, priced, federally recognized reduction in what your company is worth.

Now put it next to the ESOP guidance. NCEO, explaining when an ESOP does not work: “If the seller is the key manager, capable successor management must be in place to obtain an outside loan as well as to help assure that the company will be able to pay for the plan over time.”

The lender asks it. The appraiser asks it. The buyer’s diligence team asks it in week one. The ESOP trustee asks it. Your family has been not-asking it for six years.

This is why “we’ll just sell it” is not the escape hatch it feels like at 11pm. Selling does not remove the successor problem; it converts it into a discount and hands it to somebody else to price. And it is why the honest sequence runs the other way around: build a company that runs without you first, and every route on that table — including the family one — gets cheaper, safer and more optional.

The conversation you have been avoiding at Thanksgiving is the same question a buyer’s attorney will ask you in the first meeting. The difference is that the attorney will put a number on it.

Seven Questions to Answer Before You Decide Anything

Answer these honestly. Nobody’s watching.

  1. What is the largest number your intended successor has been solely accountable for, and for how long, and did anyone other than you ever score them on it?
  2. Has that person ever worked for someone who was not obligated to keep them?
  3. If they said no tomorrow, would you be relieved, devastated, or unsurprised? Answer with the first word that came to you.
  4. Have you ever asked them what they want, in a conversation where the company was not mentioned?
  5. Is there anyone in the business today, family or not, who could run it for ninety days if you were unavailable? Name them.
  6. If a buyer asked “who runs this without you,” what is your actual answer, out loud, in one sentence?
  7. What have you already decided, privately, that you have not told anyone?

How to read it. If you answered 1 and 2 easily and have a name for 5, you have a readiness plan to run and you probably do not need me, get your successor a real P&L, an outside advisor to assess them, and a date. If you had no answer for 4, start there and nowhere else; you may be six years into developing someone who told you no in a way you did not hear. A blank on 5 and 6 is the urgent one, and it is not a family problem, it is the thing that lowers the price of every exit on the table. And if question 3 produced “relieved,” sit with that for a week before you do anything at all. That answer is data.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

How do I know whether my daughter isn’t ready, or whether I’ve just never let her lead anything?

You mostly cannot tell from where you are standing, which is the honest answer. The test is to give her one complete area; a P&L, a function, a location, for twelve months, with a written standard and someone other than you assessing her against it. If capability grows, it was readiness. If she does the job well and still seems to be somewhere else, it was willingness. Twelve months is a short time to spend to stop guessing.

My son says he’ll do it if nobody else will. Is that good enough?

That is obligation, and the research says obligation keeps people in the building rather than making them effective in the seat. It is not nothing. Dawson and colleagues found obligation-based commitment does predict intention to stay. But it is a poor foundation for a twenty-year run, and the person paying for it will be him. I would treat “if nobody else will” as a no with good manners, and go find out what a yes would actually require.

We have no successor and I am sixty-six. What is the realistic fastest path?

Hire or promote a general manager now and give them real scope, whatever you eventually decide about ownership. That single move improves every option simultaneously: it raises what a buyer will pay, it is a precondition for an ESOP, it makes a staged family handover possible later if someone changes their mind, and it means the company survives a bad health year. Ownership questions can take another two years. That one cannot.

What does it cost to work with you on this?

Coaching and facilitation are usually a monthly retainer or a project fee, and the range is wide depending on how many people are in the room. Both of us should know whether it is worth it before you spend anything, which is why the first conversation is free. If what you actually need is an investment banker, a valuation, or an ESOP feasibility study, that is a different bill and I will say so on the call rather than after the invoice.

Where I Fit, and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct with you, because that is what I would want. I am not an investment banker, a business appraiser, a CPA or an attorney, and nothing here is tax, legal or valuation advice, the ESOP, the sale and the ownership transfer all need those people, and they should be in the room before anything is signed. I am also not an EOS Implementer; if what you need is someone to install an operating system, that is not my seat. What I do is the part that decides whether any of it works: telling the difference between a successor who cannot yet and one who will not ever, and having the conversation that gets you an honest answer.

  • The credentials behind the work. Kirsten Ross Vogel, MHRLR, SPHR, a master’s degree from Michigan State University, one of the top human resource programs in the country, and certification as a Senior Professional in Human Resources.
  • Thirty years, and generational transition is the specialism. More than 30 years working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits, from owners and CEOs to next-generation successors and their teams. The work is traversing challenging family dynamics and creating a smooth transition from the “Now Generation” to the “Next Gen,” alongside business transition and transfer planning.
  • Fluent in EOS without selling it. I am not part of the franchise and I do not sell the system. I have coached leaders and teams running on EOS for more than 25 years, so nobody has to stop and explain the vocabulary to me.
  • Endorsed by the man who built EOS. Gino Wickman, creator of EOS and author of Traction and Get A Grip: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.”
  • How the work is actually done. Team assessments built on an interview-style survey of employees, producing a Report of Findings, identified issues with specific actions prescribed to correct each one. Facilitated difficult conversations. Conflict resolution. Business transition and transfer planning. Group work for up to eight people. Individual leadership development in three steps: Awareness, Motivation, Change.
  • On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.
  • Sent here by Implementers. EOS Implementers refer more work to me than any other source. They are very good at what they do. This is simply the part that is not theirs to do.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call, a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what is really going on in your business or leadership. If the answer is that you need a banker and a valuation rather than a coach, I will say so. If the answer is that you need both, I will say that too. You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams. Most coaching sessions are held via Zoom, and in-person sessions are available at the New Hudson, Michigan office. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on one claim: the statement that EOS Implementers refer more work to Focus Forward Coaching than any other source is Kirsten’s own account of her practice, not independently published data. Every other figure and quotation in this article is sourced below. Nothing here is tax, legal or valuation advice, and the academic findings cited describe averages across large samples rather than predictions about any individual successor.

Sources

All URLs accessed August 13, 2026.

Research on successor commitment and motivation

Pramodita Sharma and P. Gregory Irving, Four Bases of Family Business Successor Commitment: Antecedents and Consequences, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 2005, vol. 29 no. 1, pp. 13–33 (the four bases: affective, normative, calculative, imperative) — https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1540-6520.2005.00067.x

Alexandra Dawson, Pramodita Sharma, P. Gregory Irving, Joel Marcus and Francesco Chirico, Predictors of Later-Generation Family Members’ Commitment to Family Enterprises, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 2013 (199 family firms — 78 Canadian, 121 Swiss; affective and normative commitment as positive predictors of intention to stay; cost-based commitment weakest and not significant) — https://spectrum.library.concordia.ca/id/eprint/978746/1/Dawson_et_al_ETP_in_press.pdf

Marylène Gagné, Connor Marwick, Stéphanie Brun de Pontet and Carsten Wrosch, Family Business Succession: What’s Motivation Got to Do With It?, Family Business Review, 2021 (12-year longitudinal study of 89 Canadian family businesses; successor confidence and perceived incumbent support predicting intrinsic motivation, which predicted successful transfer twelve years later) — https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0894486519894759

Denise Kenyon-Rouvinez and Anne-Catrin Glemser, To be, or not to be, the next-generation family business leader, IMD, June 2014 (children sensing parental expectations; the freedom to choose) — https://www.imd.org/research-knowledge/family-business/articles/to-be-or-not-to-be-the-next-generation-family-business-leader/

Research on successor performance

Irena Kustec, Charlotte Ostergaard and Amir Sasson, Underperformance in Family Successions: The Role of Outside Work Experience, working paper hosted by the European Corporate Governance Institute, December 2020 (2,579 Norwegian family-controlled firms, CEO successions 2005–2011; underperformance entirely driven by internally recruited family successors, two-thirds of whom lack outside work experience) — https://www.ecgi.global/sites/default/files/Paper:%20Irena%20Kustec,%20Charlotte%20Ostergaard%20and%20Amir%20Sasson.pdf

Francisco Pérez-González, Inherited Control and Firm Performance, American Economic Review, 2006, vol. 96 no. 5, pp. 1559–1588 (related-CEO underperformance; selective undergraduate institutions) — https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257%2Faer.96.5.1559

Morten Bennedsen, Kasper Meisner Nielsen, Francisco Pérez-González and Daniel Wolfenzon, Inside the Family Firm: The Role of Families in Succession Decisions and Performance, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2007, vol. 122 no. 2, pp. 647–691 (Danish data; firstborn-gender instrument; operating profitability on assets falling by at least four percentage points) — https://www.nber.org/papers/w12356

Valuation, exit routes and market data

Internal Revenue Service, Revenue Ruling 59-60, 1959-1 C.B. 237, Section 4.02(b) (the “one-man” business and the lack of trained personnel capable of succeeding to management), reproduced by Business Valuation Resources — https://sub.bvresources.com/FreeDownloads/IRS59-60.pdf — and corroborated against two further reproductions: https://nielsenvaluationgroup.com/revenue-ruling-59-60/ and https://www.equityvaluationappraisals.com/pdf/IRS-Revenue-Ruling-59-60.pdf

National Center for Employee Ownership, Employee Ownership by the Numbers (6,609 ESOPs, 15.1 million participants, over $2 trillion in plan assets, 5,993 privately held sponsoring companies; 2023 Department of Labor Form 5500 data) — https://www.nceo.org/research/employee-ownership-by-the-numbers

National Center for Employee Ownership, Common ESOP Myths vs. Real Benefits (leveraged ESOP costs of $150,000–$400,000 in the first year and $20,000–$30,000 annually; capable successor management required where the seller is the key manager) — https://www.nceo.org/articles/reasons-esop

National Center for Employee Ownership, ESOP Pre-Feasibility Toolkit (the 15–20 employee threshold; profitability requirement) — https://www.nceo.org/resource-toolkits/esop-pre-feasibility-toolkit

National Center for Employee Ownership, What Is Employee Ownership? (an ESOP buying a departing owner’s shares in pretax dollars) — https://www.nceo.org/what-is-employee-ownership

Gallup, Most Small-Business Owners Lack a Succession Plan (1,264 owners whose work is primarily their own business, surveyed September 20 to October 28, 2024; 26% giving away, 23% selling, 2% going public, 22% closing, a third with no plan) — https://news.gallup.com/poll/657362/small-business-owners-lack-succession-plan.aspx

Christina Wing and Rohit K. Gera, How to Bring an Outside CEO into the Family Business, Harvard Business Review, October 25, 2023 (most multigenerational family businesses eventually needing a non-family leader) — https://hbr.org/2023/10/how-to-bring-an-outside-ceo-into-the-family-business

Focus Forward Coaching

Home, including the Gino Wickman endorsement and phone number — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/

About Kirsten Ross Vogel (MLIR, SPHR, Michigan State University, 30+ years, books and media) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/about/

Coaching and services (family business strategy, “Now Generation” to “Next Gen,” team assessment and Report of Findings, groups of up to eight, Awareness–Motivation–Change) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/services/

FAQ (Discovery Call, Zoom or in person in New Hudson, 25+ years coaching leaders and teams running on EOS, who Kirsten works with) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/faq/

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights