Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Focus Forward · Relationships

Fair vs. Equal: Dividing Ownership and Roles Among Your Children; Money, Control and a Job Are Three Different Gifts

Equal shares feel like the safe choice because they postpone the argument. They do not cancel it. They hand it to your children to have later, without you in the room.

Last updated: August 13, 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MHRLR, SPHR, Focus Forward Coaching, Milford, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.

Fair and equal are not the same decision, and most of the damage I see comes from treating them as one. A share certificate quietly bundles three separate things: economic value, who receives what the company distributes and what it is eventually worth; voting control, whose decision stands when the owners disagree; and role, who has a job here, what it is, and what it pays. Those three can be divided in three different ways, in three different proportions, to three different children. Most owners collapse them into one number, “a third each”, and then find they have handed one child a job nobody can take away, handed another a stake nobody will buy, and handed no one the ability to decide anything. Separate the three deliberately, pay the child who works here a market salary rather than extra equity, and tell every child what they are getting while you are still alive to explain why.

The Three Levers Hiding Inside One Share Certificate

Every family I sit with believes it is making one decision. It is making three, and only one of them usually gets discussed.

Economic value is the money: distributions while you are alive, dividends afterward, proceeds if the company is ever sold. This is what people mean when they say “equal.”

Voting control is the authority attached to the shares, who elects the board, who approves a sale, whose vote settles a deadlock. It travels with a share class, not with a job title.

Role is employment: a seat, accountabilities, a paycheck, a review. It is the only one of the three a person can be removed from, and the only one that pays out monthly. It is also the lever you cannot decide from the estate plan, whether the child you have in mind can actually hold the seat is a separate diagnosis, and I have written it up in What to Do When the Next Generation Isn’t Ready, or Doesn’t Want, to Take Over.

Writing for IESE Business School in June 2026, Carlos García Pont states the separation about as plainly as it can be put: “One of the oldest and most effective ways is separating voting rights from economic rights: voting shares for those leading the business, non-voting shares with equal dividend rights for those who are not.” His sharper line is the one I would put on the wall: “Ownership is a role, not a reward. Inheriting shares does not make someone an owner; it merely makes them a shareholder.”

Practitioners say the same thing from the pay side. Kate Barnwell and Stephanie Brun de Pontet of The Family Business Consulting Group, writing in April 2026, warn that “it becomes important not to conflate the rewards of ownership (returns you should expect because you keep your capital in the business) and those earned as a salary for doing a job.” Mix those and the children outside the business resent the salaries while the ones inside resent the distributions, each convinced the other has not earned it. If that resentment is already live in your family rather than hypothetical, settle the argument before you sign the documents; How to Resolve Conflict Between Family Members Who Work Together is about which of the two arguments you are actually having.

That is not a values problem. It is a design problem, and design problems have design solutions.

How the Three Levers Compare

Criterion Economic value Voting control Role in the business
What it actually is Distributions, dividends, sale proceeds Whose decision stands A job, its accountabilities and its pay
Where it lives Share ownership, trust terms, operating agreement Share class and voting provisions Job description, comp plan, employment file
Can it be split equally without much harm? Usually yes. This is the lever most families can afford to make equal Rarely. Equal control among siblings is how a company deadlocks Never. A job is earned, held and lost on performance
What goes wrong when it is split equally by default Little, if control and role are handled separately Deadlock, or a permanent two-against-one the family never recovers from The standard everyone else is held to acquires an exception with a surname
Who you need in the room Estate attorney and CPA Corporate attorney You, and an honest outside read
Can it be undone later? Expensively, through a buyout Only by agreement of whoever now holds it Yes, which is exactly why it should not be paid in equity

The box owners skim past is the last one in the right-hand column. Equity is close to permanent and salary is not, and a lot of owners pay a child in the more permanent currency because it feels warmer and costs no cash this year. That is not generosity. It is a bill with a very long due date.

What About the Child Who Works Here and the Child Who Doesn’t?

This is the real question under the title, and it has been asked in print for decades. John F. Hopkins framed it in Family Business Magazine in 1997 and nothing since has improved on it: “Is it ‘fair’ to give two brothers equal shares of stock in the family firm when one has worked hard for 20 years building the business while the other has had nothing to do with it?” His conclusion is not the sentimental one: “An equal share in the family business will be equal in name only.”

Here is what an equal, undifferentiated split actually hands each child.

  • The one inside the business gets a job with a shareholder attached to it. Every raise, every truck, every decision to reinvest instead of distribute is now reviewable by a sibling with a financial interest and no operational context.
  • The one outside the business gets an asset they cannot spend. A minority stake in a private company pays what the company chooses to distribute, has no buyer and no market price. They will feel like a hostage holding a certificate.
  • Neither of them can leave. Without a buy-sell agreement setting a price and a trigger, the only exits are a negotiation neither is in a mood to have, or a lawyer.

The fix is not new. Writing in The CPA Journal in December 2023, Martin Shenkman describes “recapitalizing the entity into voting and nonvoting interests and gifting or selling (depending upon estate planning goals and the founder’s financial needs) the voting interests to the child in the business.” The economics stay broad. The steering wheel goes to one person.

But Shenkman does not stop where most articles stop. He notes that this “simplistic approach” may not be enough on its own, because “without a specific provision addressing salary, the child in the business could increase their salary and thereby unduly reduce funds available for distribution to all owners.”

Read that twice. The three levers stop being independent the moment you pull them. Give one child control and everyone equal economics, and that child now sets the salary that determines everyone else’s economics. You have not divided anything. You have built a pipe with a valve on it and handed one person the valve.

So the pay question gets settled in writing at the same time as the ownership question, not two years later. Barnwell and Brun de Pontet’s baseline is that pay for a family member should be “closely aligned with pay for a non-family employee in a similar role.” Pay the operating child a market salary for the seat they hold, with a bonus tied to results if the results are genuinely theirs, and let the ownership stake be a return on capital, the same return every other owner gets. That is the version a sibling can accept, because it can be checked against something outside the family. Setting that number defensibly, and being able to explain the method to your non-family managers without disclosing anyone’s pay, is its own discipline. I walk through it in How to Bring a Spouse, Sibling, or In-Law Into the Business Fairly.

Equalizing With Assets Outside the Business

If the business goes to the child who runs it, the others need something real. The most common tool is life insurance, and it works, with limits nobody selling it to you leads with.

University of Nebraska–Lincoln extension educators Jessica Groskopf and Cindy Bojanski describe the standard structure for farm and business families: “Mom and Dad could purchase a ‘second to die’ permanent life insurance policy on themselves and name the off-farm child as the beneficiary.” The child outside the business receives the death benefit; the child inside inherits the operating assets.

Their cautions are the useful part. “Depending on your situation, policies may be cost prohibitive or unavailable,” premiums turn on “the insured’s age, health status, occupation, lifestyle, and other factors,” and plainly: “Some people are simply uninsurable.”

Two questions before you rely on it: what the premium actually costs every year for the rest of your life, and what happens to the equalization if the business triples in value and the policy does not. An equalizing asset that was accurate in 2019 is a grievance by 2035. Whether any of this fits your situation is a question for your estate attorney and your CPA — not for me, and not for an article.

The Part Most People Miss: The Standard Fix Has a Supreme Court Problem

Most articles on this topic stop at “get a buy-sell agreement and fund it with life insurance.” True, and nowhere near enough, because how that agreement is structured decides which of your children it quietly favors, and in 2024 the Supreme Court settled that question in a way a great many family agreements were never drafted for.

Michael and Thomas Connelly were brothers and the sole shareholders of Crown C Supply, a building supply corporation. Michael held 77.18 percent, Thomas 22.82. As the Court described it, “the brothers entered into an agreement with Crown to ensure a smooth transition of ownership and keep Crown in the family in the event one of the brothers died.” That is the sentence in your file, in your handwriting, right now.

The mechanism was the ordinary one. If either brother died, the survivor had the option to buy the shares; if he declined, “then Crown itself would be contractually required to redeem the shares.” The company bought “$3.5 million in life insurance on each brother” to fund it.

Michael died. Thomas opted not to buy. Michael’s son and Thomas “agreed in an ‘amicable and expeditious manner’ that the value of Michael’s shares was $3 million,” and Crown used $3 million of the proceeds to redeem them, “leaving Thomas as Crown’s sole shareholder.” Then the IRS valued Michael’s shares at $5.3 million instead and assessed the estate an additional $889,914. On June 6, 2024, a unanimous Court sided with the IRS. Justice Thomas, writing for the Court: “We hold that Crown’s contractual obligation to redeem Michael’s shares did not diminish the value of those shares.” The insurance the company owned counted as a corporate asset. The obligation to spend it did not cancel it out.

Two things in that opinion belong in every family conversation about splitting a company.

First, the Court’s own arithmetic is the cleanest statement of fair-versus-equal I have read in a legal document. It works through a corporation holding $10 million in cash with two shareholders, A and B, owning 80 and 20 shares: “Each individual share is worth $100,000.” Redeem B’s 20 shares for $2 million and “A would be the sole shareholder in a corporation worth $8 million and with 80 outstanding shares. A’s shares would still be worth $100,000 each.” Not a dollar of anyone’s economics moved. Control moved entirely. That is the separation of the levers, demonstrated by the Supreme Court, in a case about a family business.

Second, the structure you pick allocates advantage between your children. In The CPA Journal in February 2026, James Jurinski and Lawrence Hartmann state the post-Connelly consequence bluntly: “When a business has increased in value and owns a large insurance policy, redemption format buy/sell agreements will financially favor the surviving business owners over exiting owners or the heirs of deceased owners.” In a family, “surviving business owners” and “heirs of deceased owners” are not abstractions. They are your daughter who stayed, and your other daughter’s children.

The Court named the alternative and its price in the same breath: the brothers “could have used a cross-purchase agreement — an arrangement in which shareholders agree to purchase each other’s shares at death and purchase life-insurance policies on each other to fund the agreement.” And then, honestly: “Every arrangement has its own drawbacks. A cross-purchase agreement would have required each brother to pay the premiums for the insurance policy on the other brother, creating a risk that one of them would be unable to do so.”

I am not an attorney and this is not legal or tax advice. What I am giving you is the question to walk into your attorney’s office with: which structure is ours, was it reviewed after June 2024, and which of my children does it favor if I die first? Jurinski and Hartmann’s own standing advice is that “buy/sell agreements need regular review, especially when the business changes.” Most of the agreements I meet in family companies were signed once, filed, and never opened again.

The Connellys’ agreement did exactly what it promised. It kept the company in the family. It simply decided which side of the family, and at what price, and the two men who signed it were not in the room when that got settled.

When and How Do You Tell the Children?

Late, vaguely, or never, which is the most destructive option available to you and also the most popular.

Brown Brothers Harriman’s Third Annual Private Business Owner Survey, conducted for BBH by MLR Media in July and August 2025 with 491 usable responses from family-owned and privately owned companies, found that only “38% of owners say they’ve been completely open and transparent about their wealth and estate plans with the next generation; 36% have only been somewhat open and transparent; 21% have not shared details.” An earlier wave of the same survey found “74% state that roles for the next generation are either not well-defined or not fully communicated.”

Fidelity’s 2025 Family & Finance study, fielded by Versta Research from July 21 to August 14, 2025 among parents 55 and older with at least $500,000 in investable assets and adult children aged 25 to 54 measured the appetite on the other side of the table: “76% of the next generation want to know if they are named as a beneficiary, but only 35% of baby boomers feel a need to talk.”

Three-quarters of them want to know. A third of you think it is worth saying. That gap is where the surprise-at-the-reading-of-the-will approach lives, and it is not a tax strategy. It is avoidance with paperwork around it.

Notice what the silence is actually about. Scott Clemons, commenting on BBH’s findings, points out that “in its strictest sense, an estate plan is about ownership of an asset,” and that owners routinely conflate ownership questions with management questions. That conflation is what makes the conversation feel unspeakable. You are not dreading telling your son what he inherits. You are dreading telling him he is not going to run it. Two different sentences, and only one of them is hard.

So separate them, and say them in this order:

  1. Tell each child individually first, in a scheduled conversation. Not at a holiday, not in a group. Each of them hears their own outcome from you before anyone compares notes.
  2. Say the role decision and the ownership decision as two separate statements. “You will not be running the company” and “you will own a quarter of it” are different news and deserve different sentences.
  3. Say the rule, not just the result. Not “your sister gets the voting shares,” but “the voting shares go with the seat, and the seat goes to whoever is running the company, including if that stops being your sister.”
  4. Then bring everyone together and repeat all of it in one room. The individual conversations prevent ambush. The group conversation prevents four private versions of your reasoning from taking root.
  5. Put the same explanation in writing and keep it with the documents. You will not be available for follow-up questions at the moment they matter most.

Hopkins recommended exactly this in 1997; family meetings at which the parents explain their decisions, while the parents are still there to explain them. Almost thirty years and several surveys later, the advice has not changed and almost nobody takes it. BBH’s 2025 respondents named the reason themselves: asked for the biggest challenge in succession planning, 46 percent said family dynamics, ahead of lack of a clear successor at 41 percent and tax implications at 13 percent. It was never the tax code stopping you.

Seven Questions to Answer Before You Sign Anything

Answer these honestly. Nobody’s watching.

  1. Can you say out loud, in one sentence each, who gets the money, who gets the votes and who gets the job, and are those three answers actually different?
  2. If your children end up equal owners, name the person who breaks a tie. If the honest answer is “they’ll work it out,” you have not answered.
  3. Is the child working in the business paid a salary you could defend to a non-family manager doing the same job?
  4. Is there anything in writing that stops a controlling child from raising their own pay until the distributions to everyone else disappear?
  5. Does your buy-sell agreement say what a share is worth and who has to buy it — and has anyone opened it since June 2024?
  6. If the child outside the business wanted out in five years, exactly how do they get out, at what price, paid by whom?
  7. Has every child heard their own outcome from you, in their own conversation, in words they could repeat back correctly?

How to read it. Clear and different answers to 1 and 2 mean the design work is largely done, take it to your attorney and your CPA and you may not need me at all. A blank on 3 or 4 is a compensation problem wearing an ownership costume, and it is the most fixable thing here: one honest market pay check and one written policy. Blanks on 5 and 6 are a drafting job with a date on it. A blank on 7 is the one that costs you the family, and it is the only item on this list that no professional you hire can do for you.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

Is it ever right to give the children equal shares?

Often, on the economic side. Equal economics is the least destructive place to be equal. It is how you tell four children they matter the same without pretending they do the same work. What rarely survives is equal control among siblings with no tiebreaker, and equal roles for people with unequal ability. Split the levers and you can be generous on the one that carries the message and disciplined on the two that carry the risk.

My child in the business says she built it and should own more. Is she right?

She is right that she should be paid more, and usually wrong that the way to do it is equity. Salary, bonus and a defined seat compensate work: adjustable, reviewable, and they stop when the work stops. Equity compensates capital and is close to permanent. If she is genuinely creating value beyond her role, that is an argument for a performance bonus or an earned-in stake with conditions attached, with your CPA in the room.

Should the child who doesn’t work in the business get voting shares?

That is a legal and governance question with a real answer in your state, and it is not the same answer everywhere. Whether and what duties shareholders in a closely held company owe one another varies by jurisdiction; Delaware, New York, Massachusetts and Michigan courts do not treat it identically. Ask your corporate attorney what a non-voting holder in your entity, in your state, can still do: what they can see, what they can block, what they can sue over. Do not assume “non-voting” means “no leverage.”

We’re not ready to decide. Can we just tell them later?

You can, and you should know what you are choosing. Most owners choose exactly this. Only 38 percent in BBH’s 2025 survey described themselves as completely open with the next generation, and it is the choice that turns a difficult conversation into a permanent one. You do not have to announce a finished plan. You can say: here is how I am thinking about it, here is the principle I am using, here is when I will have decided. That costs you nothing you were keeping.

What does it cost to bring you in for this?

Coaching and facilitation are usually a monthly retainer or a project fee, and what moves the number is how many people the decision runs through and whether they are all speaking to each other. I would rather establish on a free first call whether this is worth anything to you than send you an invoice and find out afterwards. And if what you actually need is an estate attorney, a valuation and an insurance review, that is a different set of bills, and I will say so on that call.

Where I Fit, and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct with you, because that is what I would want. I am not an attorney, I am not a CPA, I am not a financial advisor and I do not sell insurance. Nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice, and the structures described are jurisdiction-dependent. Your own attorney and accountant have to look at your documents, your entity and your state. I am also not an EOS Implementer. What I do is the layer underneath the paperwork: the decision about who runs this and who does not, the conversation the family has been avoiding, and whether these people are still speaking to each other after the documents are signed.

  • The credentials behind the work. Kirsten Ross Vogel, MHRLR, SPHR, a master’s degree from one of the top human resource programs in the country, Michigan State University, and certification as a Senior Professional in Human Resources.
  • Thirty years in the relationship layer. More than 30 years working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits, from owners and CEOs to next-generation successors and their teams.
  • Transition is a named service, not a sideline. Business transition and transfer planning, family business strategy, and the move from the “Now Generation” to the “Next Gen.”
  • Fluent in EOS without selling it. I am not part of the franchise. I have coached leaders and teams running on the Entrepreneurial Operating System for more than 25 years, so nobody has to stop and explain an Accountability Chart to me.
  • Endorsed by the man who built EOS. Gino Wickman, creator of EOS and author of Traction and Get A Grip: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.”
  • How the work is actually done. Team assessments that begin with an interview-style survey of employees and produce a Report of Findings, identified issues with specific prescribed actions, a customized roadmap. Facilitated difficult conversations. Conflict resolution. Group training and facilitation for up to eight people. Individual leadership development in three steps: Awareness, Motivation, Change.
  • On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.
  • Sent here by Implementers. EOS Implementers refer more work to me than any other source. They are very good at what they do. This is simply the part that is not theirs to do.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call, a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what is really going on in your business or leadership. If the answer is that you need an estate attorney and a valuation rather than a coach, I will say so. If the answer is that you need both, I will say that too. You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams. Most sessions are held via Zoom, and in-person sessions are available at the New Hudson, Michigan office. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on one claim: the statement that EOS Implementers refer more work to Focus Forward Coaching than any other source is Kirsten’s own account of her practice, not independently published data. Every other figure and quotation in this article is sourced below. Nothing here is legal, tax or insurance advice; ownership structures, shareholder duties and buy-sell mechanics differ by state and by entity type and should be reviewed with your own counsel.

Sources

All URLs accessed August 13, 2026.

Court decision and legal analysis

Supreme Court of the United States, Connelly v. United States, No. 23-146, decided June 6, 2024 — the facts of Crown C Supply, the $3.5 million policies, the $3 million redemption, the $5.3 million valuation, the $889,914 assessment, the holding, the $10 million hypothetical and the cross-purchase alternative — https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-146_i42j.pdf

Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, Connelly v. United States full text (independent reproduction used to corroborate the quoted passages) — https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/23-146

Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center, Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. (2024) (unanimous decision, opinion delivered by Justice Thomas; the additional $889,914 in tax) — https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/602/23-146/

Kirstie Brenson and Adam Diederich, Minority Shareholders and Their Fiduciary Duties: What Jurisdictions Across the Country Say, ArentFox Schiff, April 12, 2022 (state-by-state variation in shareholder fiduciary duties in closely held corporations, including Delaware, New York, Massachusetts and Michigan) — https://www.afslaw.com/perspectives/alerts/minority-shareholders-and-their-fiduciary-duties-other-jurisdictions

Ownership structure, buy-sell agreements and compensation

James Jurinski and Lawrence Hartmann, Using Buy/Sell Agreements, The CPA Journal, February 18, 2026 (cross-purchase versus redemption structures, the post-Connelly effect favoring surviving owners, and the need for regular review) — https://www.cpajournal.com/2026/02/18/using-buy-sell-agreements/

Martin Shenkman, Transitioning a Family Business to a Child in the Business, The CPA Journal, December 5, 2023 (recapitalization into voting and non-voting interests; the salary provision that protects the other owners’ distributions) — https://www.cpajournal.com/2023/12/05/transitioning-a-family-business-to-a-child-in-the-business/

Carlos García Pont, The Ownership Dimension of Succession, IESE Business School, June 17, 2026 (separating voting rights from economic rights; ownership as a role, not a reward) — https://blog.iese.edu/family-business/2026/ownership-succession/

Drew Steen, Stocks in Family Business: Voting or Nonvoting?, Davis Wright Tremaine Family Business Resource Center, June 18, 2018 (purposes and risks of dual-class structures in family companies, including the risk of economic owners who cannot control the business) — https://www.dwt.com/blogs/family-business-resource-center/2018/06/stocks-in-family-business-voting-or-nonvoting

Kate Barnwell and Stephanie Brun de Pontet, Paying Family in a Family Business: Where Good Intentions Create Hidden Risks, The Family Business Consulting Group, April 1, 2026 (market-based wages; not conflating the rewards of ownership with salary for a job) — https://www.thefbcg.com/resource/paying-family-in-a-family-business-where-good-intentions-create-hidden-risks/

John F. Hopkins, Equality Is Often Unfair, Family Business Magazine, May 30, 1997 (“equal in name only”; family meetings at which parents explain their decisions) — https://familybusinessmagazine.com/ownership/dividends-and-distributions/equality-often-unfair-0/

Jessica Groskopf and Cindy Bojanski, Ideas for Estate and Transition Planning: Life Insurance Inheritance Equalization, University of Nebraska–Lincoln Panhandle Research, Extension and Education Center (second-to-die policies naming the child outside the business; cost, insurability and availability cautions) — https://preec.unl.edu/ideas-estate-and-transition-planning-life-insurance-inheritance-equalization

Surveys and data

Brown Brothers Harriman, Third Annual Private Business Owner Survey (conducted for BBH by MLR Media by email and online survey in July and August 2025; 491 usable responses; 38% completely open with the next generation, 36% somewhat, 21% not sharing details; family dynamics named the biggest succession challenge at 46%, lack of a clear successor 41%, tax implications 13%) — https://www.bbh.com/us/en/insights/capital-partners-insights/second-annual-private-business-owner-survey.html

Brown Brothers Harriman, Second Annual Private Business Owner Survey (400 U.S. private business owners surveyed July 22 to August 2, 2024; 74% saying next-generation roles are either not well-defined or not fully communicated) — https://www.bbh.com/content/dam/bbh/external/www/capital-partners/private-banking/insights/2024-private-business-owner-survey/2024-7368213855-CP-Second%20Annual%20PBO%20Survey-PUB-final.pdf

Zack Needles, Secrets, Secrets Are No Fun, Family Business Magazine, October 4, 2024 (reporting on the BBH survey; Scott Clemons on an estate plan being, in its strictest sense, about ownership of an asset) — https://www.familybusinessmagazine.com/succession/secrets-secrets-are-no-fun/

Fidelity Investments, 2025 Family & Finance Study (national surveys by Versta Research fielded July 21 to August 14, 2025 among parents 55+ with $500,000+ in investable assets and adult children aged 25–54; 76% of the next generation wanting to know if they are named a beneficiary against 35% of baby boomers feeling a need to talk) — https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20251113062564/en

Focus Forward Coaching

Home, including the Gino Wickman endorsement and services — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/

About Kirsten Ross Vogel (MLIR, SPHR, Michigan State University, 30+ years, books and media) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/about/

Coaching and services (business transition and transfer planning, team assessment and Report of Findings, groups of up to eight, Awareness–Motivation–Change) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/services/

FAQ (Discovery Call, Zoom or in person in New Hudson, more than 25 years coaching leaders and teams running on EOS) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/faq/

Testimonials, including the Gino Wickman endorsement quoted above — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/testimonials/

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights