Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Focus Forward

Family Business Coach vs. Advisor vs. Therapist: Who Solves What

Three professionals, three different jobs — and only one of them can refuse to repeat what your family said in the room.

Last updated: 13 August 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not a licensed therapist and not an EOS Implementer.

An advisor tells you what to do about a decision. A coach works on how you and the people around you operate. A therapist treats what is clinically wrong. The advisor — your attorney, CPA, wealth manager or consultant — owes duties to a client defined in an engagement, and their expertise is the decision in front of you. The coach works on capability and on the conversations that are not happening, and in Michigan is not a licensed profession at all. The therapist is licensed by the state, holds a graduate degree and supervised clinical hours, and treats conditions. And in Michigan, the therapist is the only one of the three whose conversations the law protects from being compelled in court — which matters more in a family business than in almost any other setting.

Most owners need two of the three at once. Which two depends on whether the problem is a decision, a pattern, or a diagnosis.

What Each One Actually Is

The coach

The International Coaching Federation defines coaching as “[p]artnering with clients in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal and professional potential.” That is the whole job description, and it is deliberately about capability rather than treatment.

Coaching is not a licensed profession in Michigan. The state’s Bureau of Professional Licensing lists twenty-eight regulated health professions — acupuncture, counseling, marriage and family therapy, psychology, social work and the rest. “Coach” is not among them. Nothing stops anyone in this state from printing the title on a card. In California, the Board of Behavioral Sciences has said it plainly for its own jurisdiction: “Although life coaches are not regulated by any governmental entity, they are prohibited from practicing in the scopes of practice of the professions regulated by the Board.”

The advisor

“Advisor” in a family business usually means your attorney, your CPA, your banker, your wealth manager or a management consultant. Each is credentialed, several are regulated, and their duties are real — but they attach to a client defined in an engagement, and that client is usually the company or the person who signed.

Their confidentiality protections are also narrower than most owners assume, which I will come back to.

The therapist

In Michigan, a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist must hold a graduate degree from a COAMFTE-accredited program or an equivalent master’s or doctorate with specified coursework in family studies, family therapy methodology, human development, ethics and research; complete “at least 1,000 hours direct client contact that is obtained post-degree and supervised by a licensed MFT”; and pass the national examination administered by the Association of Marital and Family Therapy Regulatory Boards. Applications go through the Michigan Board of Marriage and Family Therapy. Licensed Professional Counselors and Licensed Psychologists have their own separate, comparable requirements — 3,000 post-degree hours for a master’s-level LPC, 2,000 post-doctoral hours plus the EPPP for a psychologist.

What makes the MFT distinctive for a business family is the unit of treatment. AAMFT puts it this way: “In marriage and family therapy, the unit of treatment isn’t just the person — even if only a single person is interviewed — it is the set of relationships in which the person is embedded.”

Side by Side

Family business coach Advisor (attorney, CPA, consultant) Licensed therapist (LMFT, LPC, psychologist)
Licensed by Nobody. Credentials exist; a license does not. State bar, state accountancy board, or nobody for consultants The State of Michigan, with a disciplinary board
What they work on Capability, conflict, the conversations not happening The decision, the document, the number Diagnosable conditions and the relationship system
Is what you say privileged in court No. Michigan’s recognized privileges are enumerated and coaching is not among them Attorney: yes. CPA: narrowly, and it fails in common situations Yes, by statute — and for MFTs, unusually strongly
Who can waive that protection Not applicable; there is nothing to waive The client — which may not be you personally For MFT work with more than one adult in the room, only all of them together
What they cannot do Diagnose or treat anything Sit in the middle of a family without a conflict Advise you on the business
If it goes wrong, who hears it You, and nobody else The bar, the accountancy board, or the courts The state licensing board
What you should hire them for The pattern The decision The diagnosis

What Nobody Tells You: Only One of These Three Can Refuse to Testify

Most articles on this topic stop at “a coach looks forward, a therapist looks back.” True enough, and not very useful when you are deciding who to put in a room with your brother.

Here is the part that actually matters in a family company, and I have never seen it written down for owners.

Michigan’s marriage and family therapy privilege, MCL 333.16911, is one of the strongest in the state’s code. Information about someone the therapist treated “is privileged information and not subject to waiver,” regardless of whether it came from the client, “from another person involved in the therapy,” from a test, or from other sources — and regardless of whether it was obtained before, during or after therapy. And then this, which is written as if somebody had a family business in mind:

“If more than 1 individual is or was involved in the marriage and family therapy performed by a licensee, the privilege is not waived for any individual unless all individuals over 18 years of age involved in the marriage and family therapy have executed the written waiver.”

Read that again with four siblings in the room. One of them cannot later decide to open the file. All of them have to sign, in writing, or the door stays shut. There are narrow exceptions — disclosure required by law, protecting someone’s health or safety, and a defense by the therapist in an action against them — but the default is closed.

Now the coach, which is to say me. Michigan Rule of Evidence 501 provides that “[p]rivilege is governed by the common law, except as modified by statute or court rule,” and the privileges Michigan recognizes are an enumerated list: attorney-client, physician-patient, psychologist-patient, social worker-client, clergy-penitent, spousal, accountant-client and a handful of others. There is no coaching privilege on it. ICF’s own Code of Ethics concedes the point rather than hiding it, requiring coaches to have “a clear agreement with client(s), sponsor(s), and other involved parties about what confidential information may need to be disclosed to the appropriate authorities, e.g., illegal activity, required by law, valid court order or subpoena.”

My confidentiality is a contract term. A valid subpoena beats a contract term. Anyone in this field who tells you otherwise has not read their own code of ethics.

The advisor sits in between, and the details surprise people. Michigan does have an accountant confidentiality statute, MCL 339.732, and it is strongly worded — a licensee “shall not disclose or divulge and shall not be required to disclose or divulge” information connected with an engagement, absent written permission. But the Michigan Bar Journal notes that because “[t]here was no accountant privilege at common law,” the statute “must be strictly construed,” and it collapses where there are common clients — which is exactly the configuration a family business creates. The federal version, IRC §7525, extends attorney-like protection to tax advice, but only “in any noncriminal tax matter before the Internal Revenue Service” and any “noncriminal tax proceeding in Federal court.” Your CPA’s federal privilege does not exist in a shareholder dispute in an Oakland County courtroom.

There is one route by which a coach or consultant gets protection, and it is worth knowing: when the engagement runs through counsel. As one firm’s litigation guidance puts it, work product can extend to “materials prepared by a party’s agent other than an attorney — such as a third-party consultant,” but “reports or statements made by or to the consultant without an attorney’s direction or supervision are presumably made in the ordinary course of business and so are not privileged.” If your situation is genuinely headed for litigation, that is a conversation to have with your attorney before you hire anyone, including me.

In a family company, the conversation you most need to have is also the one most likely to be read out loud in a deposition someday. Exactly one of these three professionals can stop that — and it is not me.

When the Problem Is Clinical, Not Structural

This is the part where a coach is supposed to disqualify herself, and most of the category does not.

ICF’s current Code of Ethics — board approved October 2024, revised May 2026 — requires a coach under Standard 4.3 to “[r]emain alert to indications that there might be a shift in the value received from the coaching relationship” and, if appropriate, to “explore changes in the coaching relationship and/or the potential for a different coach, professional, or resource.” ICF’s companion guidance is more explicit about where that referral goes: “refer the Client to other modes of support such as counseling, therapy, legal, tax, medical, nutrition, etc.,” and adds that “it is particularly important to learn how to recognize in a timely manner, when a client may be better served by another professional.”

Recognizing it in time is a skill, not a courtesy. Here is what tends to be underneath it in a business family.

  • Substance use. A 2025 practitioner piece from FamilyBusiness.org names the observable signals — “erratic spending,” “cognitive decline,” a family member appearing “intoxicated and visibly agitated” at the workplace, creating “immediate concerns about safety and professionalism.” It also notes that “[f]amilies don’t have to do this alone.”
  • Mental health more broadly. A 2021 systematic review in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health covered 51 articles on mental health in family businesses and business families across psychology, entrepreneurship and management journals, surfacing work-family conflict, stress and anxiety, addiction, workplace bullying, burnout, depression and psychological distress. The authors’ own conclusion is a warning about how little is settled: “we lack knowledge on how being involved in the family business can affect the mental health (both ill-being and well-being) of individual family members and of the family system.”
  • The thing nobody will name at a meeting. That same review notes, summarizing one practitioner study, a claim that addiction was implicated in the great majority of consulting engagements that failed to reach their goals. I am not going to quote that as a prevalence rate, because it is not one — it is one practitioner’s observation about his own failed engagements, reaching you second-hand. I mention it because the underlying point is one I recognize: some engagements do not fail on strategy.

And the symmetry matters. The therapist is fenced out of your business questions just as firmly as I am fenced out of the clinical ones. The AAMFT Code of Ethics, effective 1 January 2026, states at 3.10 that “[m]arriage and family therapists do not diagnose, treat, or advise on problems outside the recognized boundaries of their competencies.” A licensed clinician who starts advising you on your accountability chart is out of bounds in exactly the way I would be if I started diagnosing your son.

Some institutions run both lanes deliberately. The Family Institute at Northwestern University operates a family business program staffed by licensed clinicians, addressing “problems that arise at the complex intersection of the family’s relationships and its business interests.” That is a real and legitimate model. It is not what I do, and if that is what your family needs, it exists.

A Test for Which One You Need

Answer these honestly. Nobody is watching.

  1. If the problem were solved tomorrow, would the thing that changed be a document, a behavior, or a person’s health?
  2. Is there a decision with a deadline attached to it — a sale, a transfer, a tax year, a filing? Or has the deadline been “sometime” for three years?
  3. Would you be comfortable if a transcript of the conversation you need to have were read out in a legal proceeding two years from now?
  4. Has anyone in the family used the words depressed, drinking, not himself, or scared about someone else in the past six months?
  5. When your existing advisors get near this topic, do they change the subject — and have you noticed them doing it?
  6. Is what you want someone to tell you what to do, or someone to make it possible for you to say something?

How to read your answers. A document with a deadline is advisor work, and no amount of coaching substitutes for it. A behavior with no deadline is coaching work, and no amount of legal drafting will fix it. If question four landed, start with a licensed clinician — not with me, not with your attorney — and let the business questions wait two weeks. If question three made you pause, take that seriously before you choose: it is a real argument for doing the hardest part of the conversation with someone who holds a license, or for routing the engagement through your attorney. And if question six came back as “make it possible for me to say something,” that is precisely the coaching lane, and you have your answer.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

Is coaching just therapy without a license?

No, and the distinction is written into the coaching profession’s own rules rather than being a marketing line. Coaching works on capability and forward action; ICF’s Standard 4.3 and its accompanying guidance require me to notice when you would be better served by another professional and to say so. A therapist diagnoses and treats. If I found myself doing the second thing, I would be practicing outside my lane, and Michigan regulates that lane for good reasons.

Can one person do all three jobs?

Not honestly. AAMFT’s Code of Ethics fences clinicians out of matters beyond their competence; FFI’s own material on family enterprise advising states that “no single professional posesses all the content information and process skills necessary to solve every potential conflict or problem,” naming law, finance, management science and behavioral science as the four disciplines involved. What you want is not one person who claims all of it. It is people who know their edges and will name them.

Does what I tell you stay private?

Contractually, yes — and I take it seriously. Legally, it is not privileged, and I would rather you heard that from me than learned it from opposing counsel. If your situation is genuinely litigious, ask your attorney whether the engagement should run through their office, and expect a real answer about what that changes.

My brother will never agree to see a therapist. Now what?

Then you do not start there. You start with the business conversation that can actually be scheduled, and you keep the clinical question live rather than pretending it is not the thing underneath. What you should not do is hire a coach as a substitute for care that a family member needs. That is not a cheaper version of the same product.

We already have a family therapist. Do we still need anything else?

Probably, and for the same reason in reverse. A therapist working with your family is not going to write your accountability chart, price your buy-sell, or facilitate a meeting about who gets the general manager role. Those are business conversations that happen to have family in them. Running them past a clinician who has told you they do not advise outside their competence is unfair to everyone.

Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct, because that is what I would want.

  • I am not a licensed therapist. I do not diagnose, I do not treat, and if what your family needs is clinical care, I will tell you and stop. That is not modesty; it is the rule.
  • I am not an attorney or a CPA, and nothing here is legal or tax advice. The statutes cited above are quoted so you can look them up, not so you can rely on my reading of them.
  • I am not an EOS Implementer, and I do not sell the system. I have coached leaders and teams running on EOS for more than 25 years, and Implementers refer work to me.
  • Credentials: MLIR — a master’s from Michigan State University in Labor and Industrial Relations — and SPHR, the Senior Professional in Human Resources certification from HRCI.
  • 30+ years working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits — on family dynamics, generational transition, leadership development, conflict and team drama.
  • How I work: team assessments producing a Report of Findings that pairs every issue with a prescribed action; facilitated difficult conversations; conflict resolution; business transition and transfer planning; group coaching up to eight people; individual leadership development in three steps — Awareness, Motivation, Change.
  • On the record: author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s. Gino Wickman, who created EOS and wrote Traction, has said: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.”

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call. It is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what is really going on. If what you describe belongs to an attorney, I will say so. If it belongs to a licensed clinician, I will say that too, and I will not try to talk you into hiring me first.

You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams.

Sessions run via Zoom or in person in New Hudson, Michigan. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on sources: Michigan’s legislature site could not be reached directly for this article, so every statutory quotation above was taken from two independent legal reproductions — Justia and FindLaw — and used only where the wording matched exactly. Where the reproductions abridged rather than reproduced a subsection, I have paraphrased and attributed rather than quoted. The description of my own services and credentials is my account of my practice; everything else is sourced below.

Sources

All URLs accessed 13 August 2026, except Focus Forward Coaching pages, last verified 10 August 2026.

Michigan statutes and evidence rules (via legal reproductions)

Licensure and regulation

Professional codes and definitions

Clinical issues in family enterprise

Focus Forward Coaching

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights