Everybody tells you to vet the person. Almost nobody tells you to vet the paperwork — which is the only part of this that is enforceable.
Last updated: 13 August 2026
By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.
Ask about the engagement, not the résumé. By the time you are choosing between two consultants, you have already checked their background, and the difference between a good outcome and an expensive one will not be their biography — it will be nine things that either are or are not written into your agreement. What happens to what your employees tell them. Whether any of it is protected if there is later a dispute. What the total estimate is. What counts as done. Who else pays them. Who owns the work product. How it ends. Whether they will recruit your people afterward. And what they are already worried about.
Ask those nine before you sign, and get the answers in the engagement letter rather than in a nice conversation.
Why the Paperwork Is the Part That Matters
There is a widespread and reasonable assumption that professional bodies stand behind the people who belong to them. In this field, that assumption is worth checking.
The Family Firm Institute is the international body for family enterprise professionals — multidisciplinary, running certificate programs since 2001, and describing itself as dedicated for “more than forty years” to educating professionals who serve family enterprises. It publishes Best Practices, adopted September 2019, and they are good ones. They require members to state in writing at the outset “whose interests he or she is representing,” to keep client information and “the identity of the client” confidential, to accept only engagements for which they “possess the requisite proficiencies,” to disclose conflicts, and to disclose referral fees.
And then, at the bottom of the same page:
“Membership in FFI creates no express or implied duty to adhere to the above Best Practices. FFI does not undertake or assume, and specifically disclaims, any responsibility for monitoring or reviewing the conduct of its members or their adherence to the above suggested Best Practices. These Best Practices are not intended to be relied upon by clients of FFI members, or by any other third parties.”
That is not a scandal. It is a membership organization being careful, and it is more candid than most. But read it as a buyer: the field’s own standards explicitly tell you not to rely on them. Which leaves exactly one document that binds anybody to anything, and you are the one who has to ask for it.
The Nine Questions
1. What happens to what my employees tell you?
This is the question I would ask first, and almost nobody does. If a consultant interviews your people — and any assessment worth having involves interviewing your people — the notes from those interviews exist somewhere, and someone owns them.
Doug Baumoel of Continuity Family Business Consulting has written the sharpest published version of this advice for families: insist “that the consultants’ notes and emails will not be considered ‘work product’ and, therefore, disclosable to the company or individual footing the bill,” and “[e]nsure that appropriate nondisclosure agreements are signed.” His underlying point is one I would sign my name to: “It is crucial for family stakeholders to know that what they share with their chosen consultant will be held in the confidence intended by each stakeholder.”
Ask specifically: who reads the raw notes, who reads only the summary, are individuals identifiable in the report, and what happens to the file when the engagement ends. ICF’s Code of Ethics requires coaches to “[m]aintain, store and dispose of any records, including electronic files and communications, created during my professional interactions in a manner that promotes confidentiality, security and privacy” — so a coach should already have an answer.
And do not let anyone promise your employees more than can be delivered. The EEOC has been explicit for decades that in an investigation context, “[a]n employer cannot guarantee complete confidentiality.” SHRM’s coverage of the same problem quotes employment counsel plainly: employers “cannot guarantee that an investigation will stay confidential,” and the practical advice from Baker Donelson’s Martha Boyd is to work “with an eye toward narrowing any promises of confidentiality.” A consultant who promises your workforce blanket anonymity is either uninformed or willing to say a comfortable thing.
2. If this ends up in a dispute, is any of it protected?
Usually, no — and the point of asking is to find that out on purpose rather than by surprise.
Where an inquiry into your company might later matter legally, the protection depends almost entirely on who directs it. As one firm’s guidance on internal investigations puts it, “the best way to ensure that information developed in an internal investigation will be protected from unwanted disclosure is to have an attorney direct the investigation,” and interviews “can be conducted by investigators or, for example, forensic accountants, without sacrificing the protections of the attorney-client privilege, so long as the actions of these non-attorneys are being directed by counsel.”
The case law is unforgiving about the reverse. Commentary on United States ex rel. Barko v. Halliburton Co. records the reasons privilege failed there: the investigations “were undertaken pursuant to regulatory law and corporate policy rather than for the purpose of obtaining legal advice”; employees interviewed “were never informed that the purpose of the investigation was to assist [the company] with obtaining legal advice”; and the investigation “was conducted by non-attorneys.”
You are not hiring a consultant to prepare for litigation, and I am not suggesting you should. But if there is a live shareholder dispute, a departure that might become a claim, or a family member whose exit is being negotiated, that is a conversation to have with your attorney before the consultant starts — not after the notes exist.
3. What is the total estimate, and how is it phased?
Not the hourly rate. The total, and the shape.
IMC USA’s Code of Ethics commits members to “agree in advance with a client on the basis for fees and expenses.” Practitioners in this specific field have described publicly how they do it: Ernesto J. Poza has said he developed “a proposal broken down in phases over a period of 15 months, with dollars attached to each phase,” and Thomas D. Davidow that he writes “a letter that scopes out for the client what we are going to do, what we are going to accomplish, and what it is going to cost.”
Phases are the useful part. A phased proposal gives you a decision point that is not “cancel the whole thing,” which is the only reason most bad engagements run to term.
4. What are the acceptance criteria?
Ask it in those words. They come from a standard, and consultants who work to standards will recognize them.
ISO 20700:2017, the international guideline for management consultancy services, sets out what a contracting agreement should contain, and its clause 5.5 names the elements one by one: Context; Services and deliverables; Approach and work plan; Roles and responsibilities; Acceptance criteria; Terms and conditions. The standard’s stated aim for this stage is that “[t]he client and MCSP reach a clear agreement on the scope and approach of the service to be provided and commit to working together.”
AICPA’s Statement on Standards for Consulting Services requires much the same of CPAs: establish an understanding “about the responsibilities of the parties and the nature, scope, and limitations of services to be performed, and modify the understanding if circumstances require a significant change during the engagement.”
Note the word limitations. What is this engagement not going to do? If nobody has written that down, it will be discovered later, usually by you.
5. What are your significant reservations about this engagement?
This is my favorite question in the list, because the answer is supposed to be volunteered.
AICPA’s consulting standards require a member to inform the client of “(a) conflicts of interest that may occur pursuant to the ‘Integrity and Objectivity Rule’ of the code, (b) significant reservations concerning the scope or benefits of the engagement, and (c) significant engagement findings or events.”
Significant reservations concerning the benefits of the engagement. Somebody with real experience always has one. If you ask a consultant what worries them about your situation and they tell you nothing does, you have learned that they either have not thought about it or will not say so — and both of those cost you later.
6. Who else pays you?
Family businesses are sold to constantly by people who genuinely mean well and whose recommendations happen to lead to a product.
IMC USA’s code commits members not to “accept commissions, remuneration, or other benefits from a third party in connection with the recommendations to a client without that client’s prior knowledge and consent,” and to “disclose in advance any financial interests in goods or services that form part of such recommendations.” FFI’s Best Practices require disclosure of “the nature of any business relationship” behind a referral and “whether there will be any referral fee or other fee sharing.”
Disclosure alone is not enough, and the SEC has said so in a different but instructive context: full disclosure and consent “do not themselves satisfy the adviser’s duty to act in the client’s best interest,” and “disclosure that an adviser ‘may’ have a particular conflict, without more, is not adequate when the conflict actually exists.” The CFP Board goes further still, requiring that a conflict be managed, not merely confessed.
There is a clean way to say this from the consultant’s side. The Family Business Consulting Group describes the role as one that “[i]s not motivated to manage your money, sell your business, or sell you insurance,” while acknowledging that a family genuinely needs those services too — from other people. Ernesto Poza’s version is one line: “I am very clear with my clients that I do not accept referral fees if I refer them to, say, an attorney or financial consultant.”
7. Who owns the work product and the data?
ISO 20700 names “Data protection and confidentiality” and “Protection of intellectual property” as required policy areas for a consulting engagement. The ICMCI checklist built on that standard puts them as items you should be able to tick: “We protect our confidential data and information and safeguard the rights of privacy of stakeholders” and “We protect our intellectual property and the rights of the clients intellectual property.”
There is a second half to this that owners rarely think about. IMC USA’s code commits members not to “take advantage of proprietary or privileged information, either for use by myself, the client’s firm, or another client, without the client’s permission.” Your competitor down the road may be next quarter’s engagement. Ask what travels.
8. How does this end?
Here is a verified gap worth knowing about. FFI’s Best Practices contain no provision on terminating or withdrawing from an engagement. Neither does the AICPA’s consulting standard. ISO 20700 has a closure clause, but the substantive text sits behind a paywall.
The ICF Code of Ethics does address it, requiring coaches to “[r]espect all parties’ right to terminate the coaching relationship at any point for any reason during the coaching process subject to the provisions of the agreement,” and to resolve conflicts of interest by “suspending temporarily or ending the professional relationship.”
So the exit is another thing that lives, if it lives anywhere, in your agreement. Ask: what notice, what is owed, what happens to the notes, and what happens to a half-finished process inside your family.
9. Will you approach my people afterward?
An odd question until you know the provision exists. IMC USA’s code includes a commitment to “refrain from inviting an employee of an active or inactive client to consider alternative employment without prior discussion with the client.”
Someone who has spent four months interviewing your leadership team knows exactly who your best non-family manager is. It costs one sentence in the agreement.
The Part Most People Miss: A Standard You Cannot Enforce Is a Preference
Most articles on hiring a consultant end at credentials — check the letters after the name, check the references, check the specialization. All fine, all worth doing, and none of it binding on anybody.
Look at what the research above actually adds up to. FFI publishes strong standards and disclaims responsibility for whether members follow them. AICPA’s consulting standards bind CPAs only. IMC USA’s code binds its members only. ISO 20700 is a voluntary guideline that a consultant may or may not have read. None of these bodies licenses anyone to work with your family, and none of them will hear your complaint.
That is not a reason to distrust the field. It is a reason to understand where the leverage actually sits, and it is not where buyers usually look for it. Everything in the nine questions above exists in one professional standard or another. Any of them can be moved into your engagement letter by asking. Once it is in there, it stops being an aspiration and becomes a term.
A best practice nobody can enforce is a preference. Your engagement letter is the only place any of it turns into a promise.
What Actually Goes Wrong After You Sign
Worth knowing what you are buying insurance against. Dennis T. Jaffe, writing in Family Business Magazine in 2024 about engagements that stall, describes the pattern precisely: “A carefully worded agreement is either never shared or never signed. A values statement or family governance plan is agreed upon but never implemented.” The reason is not that the work was wrong. It is that “while people may wish for resolution, want to agree and feel the warmth of harmony, they harbor deep reservations internally,” and implementing agreements “means dealing with uncomfortable changes that lead the family into new, anxiety-raising territory.”
His operational diagnosis is the one to write into the agreement: “If there is no point person or accountability, it is hard to make something happen, especially if it is new, scary or difficult.” Families should “determine the final steps needed to reach each goal they have defined and the individuals responsible for overseeing those actions.”
The academic literature points at the consultant’s side of the same failure. A 2009 Virginia Tech dissertation, quoting Upton and colleagues, records that “the most common mistakes made by consultants in dealing with the family firms are their inability to understand family dynamics, focusing on symptoms rather than problems, and inappropriate communication with members.”
Symptoms rather than problems. That is the one to watch for in a proposal.
Five Things to Decide Before the First Call
These are not questions for the consultant. They are questions for your family, and getting them wrong is the most common way an engagement fails before it starts.
Answer them honestly. Nobody is watching.
- Why now? Of everyone involved, who agrees the company needs outside help now — and who disagrees? (These are the pre-contract questions Imber-Black posed in 1986, and they still sort more engagements than anything on the consultant’s side.)
- Are you prepared to share the business secrets and the family ones? Family Business Magazine‘s version of this is blunt: “How about all our family secrets, like who hates whom? Lying doesn’t help!”
- Have you agreed on what outcome you actually want, or has each of you privately hired this person for a different job?
- What is the budget, and how long can you stand to have someone from outside among you?
- Are you prepared to accept a recommendation you will not like — including one about a family member with your surname?
How to read your answers. If question one produces a name in the “disagrees” column, deal with that before you sign, not in month two. If question three is unresolved, you are about to pay someone to discover that the family wants three different things, which is useful information at a bad price. And if the honest answer to question five is no, say so out loud to whoever you hire. A good consultant would rather know.
Questions Leaders Ask Me About This
Isn’t asking all of this going to make me look difficult?
It will make you look like someone who has done this before. Every question above traces to a published standard that professionals in this field already work to — the fee basis, the acceptance criteria, the conflicts disclosure, the records handling. Asking is not an accusation. Watching how someone answers is the actual test, and it takes about ten minutes.
We’ve never used an engagement letter with anyone. Is that a problem?
For a two-hour conversation, no. For anything that involves interviewing your employees, touching succession, or lasting more than a month, yes. Not because you expect a dispute, but because writing it down is how you discover you and the consultant were picturing two different projects — and it is much cheaper to discover that in a document than in month four.
What if the consultant is a family friend or came from our attorney?
Then ask question six anyway, and ask it more carefully rather than less. FFI’s own Best Practices require disclosure of the business relationship behind any referral and whether a fee is being shared. A referral from a trusted advisor is a good sign about competence and tells you nothing about the fee arrangement. Both things can be true.
Do these questions apply to you?
Yes, all nine, and I would rather you asked me than skipped them. I will tell you what happens to interview notes, what the phases are and what each costs, what I think will not work, that I take no referral fees, and what would make me end an engagement. If any of that came back vague from anyone — me included — that is your answer.
We hired a consultant before and nothing happened. What went wrong?
Statistically likely: nothing was wrong with the analysis. Jaffe’s account is that agreements get made and never implemented, because implementing them requires uncomfortable change and because no one was named as accountable. When you rehire, put the point person and the final steps in the agreement, and ask what the consultant does when the family stops returning calls in month three. Someone who has done this work has an answer ready.
Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not
Let me be direct, because that is what I would want if I were about to sign something.
- I am not an EOS Implementer, and I do not sell the system. If what you need is an operating system installed, I will tell you on the call rather than after the invoice. I have coached leaders and teams running on EOS for more than 25 years, and Implementers refer work to me.
- I am not an attorney or a CPA. Nothing here is legal advice, and if your situation is heading toward a dispute, your attorney should be in the conversation before I am.
- I take no referral fees. When I send you to an Implementer, an attorney or a clinician, I am not paid for it.
- Credentials: MLIR — a master’s from Michigan State University in Labor and Industrial Relations — and SPHR, the Senior Professional in Human Resources certification from HRCI.
- 30+ years working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits.
- What an engagement looks like here: team assessments — an interview-style survey of employees in a safe space where they can share openly, producing a Report of Findings that pairs every issue with a prescribed action; facilitated difficult conversations; conflict resolution; business transition and transfer planning; group coaching up to eight people; individual leadership development in three steps — Awareness, Motivation, Change.
- On the record: author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s. Gino Wickman, who created EOS and wrote Traction, has said: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.”
Where to Start
Schedule a Discovery Call. It is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what is really going on in your business — and a decent place to try the nine questions on somebody. If the answer is that you need an Implementer, an attorney or a licensed clinician instead, I will say so.
You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams.
Sessions run via Zoom or in person in New Hudson, Michigan. Call 248-973-7595.
A note on sources: ISO 20700:2017 is a paid standard. The clause headings quoted above come from the publicly available preview of its contents; I have not quoted the substantive text of clauses I could not open, and have said which is which. The Upton and Imber-Black material reaches this article through a 2009 dissertation that quotes them, and is attributed accordingly rather than as though the originals were read. The description of my own services, credentials and referral-fee practice is my account of my practice; everything else is sourced below.
Sources
All URLs accessed 13 August 2026, except Focus Forward Coaching pages, last verified 10 August 2026.
Professional standards and codes
- Family Firm Institute — Best Practices (adopted September 2019: stating the client in writing, confidentiality, scope of competence, conflicts, referral-fee disclosure — and FFI’s disclaimer of any duty to adhere)
- Family Firm Institute — About (multidisciplinary orientation; more than forty years)
- AICPA — Statement on Standards for Consulting Services No. 1 (understanding with the client; nature, scope and limitations; significant reservations concerning scope or benefits)
- ISO 20700:2017 — Guidelines for management consultancy services (official scope); publicly available preview (clause 5.5 contents including acceptance criteria; policy areas 4.4.7 and 4.4.8)
- CMC-Global / ICMCI — ISO 20700 checklist (data protection and intellectual property items)
- IMC USA — Code of Ethics (fee basis agreed in advance; third-party commissions; use of client information; approaching client employees)
- ICF Code of Ethics (records handling; right to terminate; resolving conflicts of interest)
Confidentiality of employee interviews and privilege
- Continuity Family Business Consulting — “How to Engage a Family Business Consultant,” Doug Baumoel, 1 March 2024 (notes and emails not treated as disclosable work product; scope, timelines, costs, deliverables)
- Pietragallo Gordon Alfano Bosick & Raspanti — “Preserving Privilege in Internal Investigations,” 21 November 2024 (attorney direction as the protective factor)
- StoneTurn — “Safeguarding Privilege Between Counsel and Investigations,” 1 August 2025 (the Barko findings; labeling and retention practice)
- EEOC — Enforcement Guidance: Vicarious Liability for Unlawful Harassment by Supervisors (an employer cannot guarantee complete confidentiality)
- SHRM — “Employers Can’t Guarantee Complete Confidentiality in Investigations,” 3 November 2022
- Legal Dive — employment investigations and confidentiality, 13 December 2022 (narrowing promises of confidentiality)
Conflicts of interest and independence
- SEC — Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers, 12 July 2019 (disclosure and consent do not by themselves satisfy the duty; “may” have a conflict is inadequate where one exists)
- CFP Board — The Duty to Disclose and Manage Material Conflicts of Interest, 26 November 2019 (conflicts must be managed, not only disclosed)
- The Family Business Consulting Group — “Why the World Needs Family Business Consultants,” Drew S. Mendoza, 5 April 2017 (not motivated to manage your money, sell your business, or sell you insurance)
- Family Business Magazine — “All You Need to Ask When Hiring a Consultant” (Poza on phased proposals and refusing referral fees; Davidow on the scoping letter)
How engagements fail
- Family Business Magazine — “Finish What You Started,” Dennis T. Jaffe, 5 August 2024 (agreements never signed or implemented; the need for a point person and named accountability)
- Family Business Magazine — “Tips on Hiring a Family Business Consultant,” Scott Chase, 5 December 2023 (family readiness questions, including secrets and budget)
- Ines Carolina Castanos, Family Business Consultation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, 2009 (quoting Upton et al. 1993 on common consultant mistakes; Imber-Black 1986 on pre-contract questions)
Focus Forward Coaching
- Focus Forward Coaching · About · Coaching · Testimonials (credentials, services, delivery, phone number, Wickman endorsement)