Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Drama Free Work · Focus Forward

What Team Drama and a Botched Succession Really Cost You: The Numbers Nobody Puts on the P&L

Every one of these costs is real, most of them are large, and almost none of them have a line on your income statement. Here is where they actually land — including the one that eventually arrives as a tax bill.

Last updated: August 13, 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.

The cost of team drama and an unplanned succession is paid almost entirely in accounts that hide it. It shows up as replacement hiring, as absorbed salaried hours, as output you never got from payroll you already spent — and, at the end, as a valuation discount and a tax deadline. Gallup puts the cost of replacing one employee at one-half to two times that person’s annual salary, and none of that posts as a “conflict” expense. It posts as wages, recruiting fees and overtime. The one number I will not give you is a return-on-investment figure for coaching, because nobody has published one with a method I would defend. What I can give you is the cost side, sourced, so you can do the arithmetic yourself against a price you’ll get on a call.

Two Terms Worth Defining First

Voluntary separation (a “quit”). The US Bureau of Labor Statistics counts quits as separations initiated by the employee. In June 2026 the national quits rate was 2.0% of employment per month, and the total separations rate — quits, layoffs, discharges, everything — was 3.4% (BLS JOLTS, released August 4, 2026). Those are your benchmarks.

Adjusted gross estate. An estate tax term that matters later: it is the figure your closely held business interest gets measured against to decide whether your family can pay the estate tax in installments instead of all at once.

What the Drama Costs While It Is Still Just Drama

Start with the part everybody feels and nobody meters: time.

The most widely quoted figure comes from the CPP Global Human Capital Report Workplace Conflict and How Businesses Can Harness It to Thrive, a survey of 5,000 full-time employees across nine countries conducted in May 2008. It found that US employees spend 2.8 hours per week dealing with conflict — approximately $359 billion in paid hours in 2008 — and that 18% of employees say people have left the organization because of conflict. That report is from 2008 and I’m telling you so up front. Use it for scale, not measurement: 2.8 hours is roughly 7% of a full-time week, and you pay for all of it at full salary.

The current picture comes from Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace 2026, which reports global employee engagement at 20% and states that low engagement cost the world economy approximately $10 trillion in lost productivity, or 9% of GDP. Global, not yours — but the mechanism is the one running in your company. You don’t lose money on disengagement by writing checks. You lose it by getting less back from checks you already wrote.

The largest single lever on that is the person running the team. Gallup’s State of the American Manager, drawn from engagement data covering 27 million employees and more than 2.5 million work units, found that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores across business units. In a family company, that manager is frequently a relative — and frequently the one person nobody has ever given feedback to.

Then it becomes turnover. Gallup’s 2019 analysis This Fixable Problem Costs U.S. Businesses $1 Trillion states that replacing an individual employee can cost one-half to two times that employee’s annual salary, and that 52% of voluntarily exiting employees say their manager or organization could have done something to prevent them from leaving. Read that second number again. Just over half the people who walked out could have been kept, and the intervention was a conversation.

The recruiting spend is the smallest part of the bill and the only part that arrives as an invoice. SHRM’s 2026 Recruiting Executives Benchmarking report, based on 4,657 SHRM members surveyed November 24, 2025 to January 23, 2026, puts median cost-per-hire at $1,300 for nonexecutive roles and $15,000 for executive roles. Notice how far that sits from “one-half to two times annual salary.” The gap is everything your accounting system never captures: the vacancy, the ramp, the lost knowledge, the overtime, and the manager who spent six weeks hiring instead of running a department.

Where the Money Actually Goes

Cost category What it costs Source and method Where it shows up in your accounts
Replacing a good manager One-half to two times that person’s annual salary Gallup, This Fixable Problem Costs U.S. Businesses $1 Trillion, March 13, 2019 Nowhere as itself. It disperses into wages, overtime, recruiting and training
The recruiting spend alone Median $1,300 per nonexecutive hire, $15,000 per executive hire; 39 and 45 calendar days median time-to-fill SHRM, 2026 Recruiting Executives Benchmarking, 4,657 members, fieldwork Nov 24, 2025 – Jan 23, 2026 Recruiting and advertising; agency invoices. The only visible line here
Unplanned separations US benchmark: quits 2.0% of employment per month, total separations 3.4%, June 2026 BLS Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, released Aug 4, 2026 Not an expense line — a rate you calculate yourself from your own headcount
Time spent on conflict 2.8 hours per US employee per week; ~$359 billion in US paid hours in 2008 CPP Global Human Capital Report, 5,000 employees, nine countries, May 2008. Dated; use for scale Fully absorbed into salaried payroll. Structurally invisible
Lost output from disengagement ~$10 trillion globally, ~9% of global GDP; engagement at 20% Gallup, State of the Global Workplace 2026 Not a cost at all in bookkeeping terms. It is revenue that never arrived
Delayed decisions during a stalled transition No defensible published figure — estimate it from your own payroll and your own stalled decision list — Deferred capex, missed bids, roles held open
Forced liquidity at transfer Federal estate tax at rates up to 40%; 2026 basic exclusion amount $15,000,000 per decedent; Form 706 due nine months after death IRS 2026 inflation adjustments; Instructions for Form 706 Not your P&L — the estate’s. Unless the company is sold or redeems stock to fund it
Discount for owner dependence No defensible published percentage. But the IRS’s own valuation guidance recognizes the effect Rev. Rul. 59-60, reproduced in the IRS LB&I S Corporation Valuation Job Aid Once only — at sale, gift or death, when the number is final

Two rows say “no defensible published figure.” I left them empty on purpose. There are advisors who will fill those cells with a percentage, and if you ask where it came from you will get a shrug in a nice font.

The Part Most People Miss

Most articles stop at “conflict is expensive and turnover is costly.” True, and not very useful to you, because both are costs you can talk yourself out of. The fight is a family matter. The departure was for other reasons.

Here is what changes the conversation. Third parties have already priced your family situation, and one of them is the federal government.

Look at how the IRS instructs its own valuation professionals. Revenue Ruling 59-60 — the foundational guidance on valuing stock in a closely held corporation, reproduced in full in the IRS’s own Large Business & International job aid — says this:

“The loss of the manager of a so-called ‘one-man’ business may have a depressing effect upon the value of the stock of such business, particularly if there is a lack of trained personnel capable of succeeding to the management of the enterprise.”

That is not a coach talking about legacy. That is the tax authority, in guidance standing since 1959, stating that a business dependent on one person with nobody trained behind them is worth less. Your unwillingness to name a successor is a valuation input. It always was.

Then Congress wrote an entire relief provision for what happens when an owner dies and the family can’t pay the tax without selling the business. Internal Revenue Code § 6166 lets an executor elect to pay the estate tax attributable to a closely held business in as many as ten annual installments — but only where the value of that interest exceeds 35% of the adjusted gross estate, and only where it meets the statute’s definition: a sole proprietorship, or a partnership or corporation in which the decedent held 20% or more, or which had 45 or fewer partners or shareholders.

Read that as an owner rather than as a taxpayer. The statute exists because the alternative — families liquidating a working company to meet a nine-month deadline — happened often enough that the law needed a mechanism for it. Relief provisions are archaeological evidence. They tell you what went wrong often enough to legislate about.

For 2026 the basic exclusion amount is $15,000,000 per decedent, so many family businesses will never file an estate tax return at all. Fine. The point doesn’t depend on the threshold. Owner dependence is a priced condition, and the price is set by people who have never met your family and won’t be moved by the story.

The second vein: the exits you didn’t cause and can’t see.

Nobody writes “the owner’s son yelled at his sister in shipping again” on an exit interview form. They write “pursuing another opportunity.” People who leave over conflict rarely say so to the person signing their final check, and never in a way that codes to a category in your HR system.

So your best supervisor resigns, you record a voluntary separation, you spend one-half to two times her salary replacing her, and the entry in your books says wages. The ledger records the cost with perfect accuracy and total silence about the cause. That’s the real accounting problem with family drama. Not that it’s expensive — that it’s expensive in a currency your bookkeeping converts on the way in.

The IRS wrote a relief provision for the family that ran out of time. Nobody wrote one for the family that ran out of goodwill.

Do This Arithmetic on Your Own Business

Not a quiz, no score. Six numbers, pulled from your own payroll. Nobody’s watching.

  • Your separations rate. Last month’s departures divided by headcount, against the June 2026 national rates of 3.4% total separations and 2.0% quits. Run twelve months and read the trend, not the month.
  • Your replacement bill. Add up the salaries of everyone who left voluntarily in the last twelve months. Multiply by 0.5 for a floor and 2.0 for a ceiling, per Gallup’s published range. That is a defensible range for what turnover cost you — using your payroll, not mine.
  • The half that was preventable. Halve that range, per Gallup’s finding that 52% of voluntary leavers said it could have been prevented. That’s the portion addressable by somebody having a conversation.
  • Your conflict hours. Take the salaried people closest to the friction and estimate honestly how many hours a week each spends managing it, routing around it or recovering from it. Multiply by loaded hourly cost — BLS puts private-industry total compensation at $46.60 per hour worked as of March 2026, of which 30.1% is benefits, so use your wage figure plus roughly a third.
  • The decision list. Write down every decision sitting still because two family members won’t agree, and put a dollar figure next to each: the bid not submitted, the equipment not bought, the role not filled. This total is usually the largest and always the one nobody has written down.
  • The 35% test. Estimate the business interest as a share of the owner’s total estate. Over 35% and IRC § 6166 is a provision your family may one day need — a good reason to have the conversation while everyone can still take part in it.

If you run those six and the totals come out small, you don’t need me. Go run your company. I would rather you learn that from your own spreadsheet than from an invoice.

Why I Won’t Hand You an ROI Number for Coaching

Because I can’t source one, and this article has spent two thousand words telling you to check sources.

The most-circulated coaching ROI claims trace back to industry-commissioned research. The International Coaching Federation’s own summary cites a PwC/ARC global survey reporting “an average ROI of seven times the cost of employing a coach,” plus an FMI figure that 87% of respondents agreed executive coaching has a high ROI. ICF publishes those numbers without sample sizes, fieldwork dates or method. That doesn’t make them false. It makes them unusable as the basis for your spending decision, and I’m not going to launder them through my own site.

The honest structure is simpler. The cost side is above, sourced, and you’ve just built your own version of it. The price side is a number you get from me on a free Discovery Call; I don’t publish it because the work is scoped to the situation. Put your number next to mine and do the division. That’s your arithmetic, and you’re better positioned for it than I am.

One client’s published account: “Kirsten has helped resolve many interoffice conflicts and tensions in very quickly. The office runs smooth and more work gets done.” — Nick Tonkin, Director of Corporate Wellness. That’s a testimonial, not a measurement, and I’m labeling it as such.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

Isn’t some conflict healthy? Aren’t you pricing something we should want?

Disagreement about the business is healthy, and I’d worry about a leadership team that never had any. What costs money is unresolved conflict about people — the same argument, recurring, with no forum and no decision at the end. The 2.8-hours-a-week figure isn’t measuring productive debate. It’s measuring the friction, avoidance and recovery around fights that never conclude.

How would I know whether a departure was really caused by the family situation?

Usually you wouldn’t, from the exit interview. What you can see is pattern: whether departures cluster in the departments closest to the family friction, whether they follow specific events, and whether the people leaving are the ones with the most options. If your best people are the ones going and every exit interview says “another opportunity,” you’re looking at the shape of the thing rather than the thing.

We’re nowhere near a $15 million estate. Does the tax material apply to us?

The estate tax probably won’t touch you, and I wouldn’t have you plan around it. The valuation point still applies, and it applies at every size. Rev. Rul. 59-60’s observation about a one-man business with nobody trained to succeed to management describes what a buyer, a lender or an appraiser sees — whether or not a Form 706 is ever filed.

What does working with you cost?

I don’t publish it, because scope depends on what’s actually going on; a facilitated conversation between two people is different work from a team assessment across a company. You get the number on the Discovery Call, before you commit to anything, alongside my honest read on whether the work is worth it in your situation.

We already run on EOS. Doesn’t that handle this?

An operating system gives you a forum and a cadence, and that helps. It doesn’t by itself resolve a decade-old disagreement between two people who share a last name. I’ve coached leaders and teams running on EOS for more than 25 years, and I work the layer underneath it, alongside the system.

Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct, because that’s what I’d want. If you ran the six calculations and the numbers came out small, you don’t need me. And several items in this article need an accountant, an appraiser or an estate attorney rather than a coach — I’m not those, and I’ll say so on the call rather than after the invoice.

  • Credentials. MLIR — a master’s degree in Human Resources from Michigan State University — and SPHR, Certified Senior Human Resource Professional.
  • Experience. More than 30 years with passionate leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits. Focus Forward Coaching launched over 25 years ago.
  • Specialty. Family business strategy is a core specialty: navigating challenging family dynamics and creating a smooth transition from the Now Generation to the Next Gen.
  • EOS fluency without EOS affiliation. Not an EOS Implementer, not part of the franchise. I’ve coached leaders and teams running on the Entrepreneurial Operating System for more than 25 years.
  • Method. Team assessments begin with an interview-style survey of employees in a safe space where they can share openly, producing a Report of Findings that pairs identified issues with specific prescribed actions.
  • On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call. It’s a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what’s really going on in your business or leadership. Bring the six numbers if you ran them — the call is far more useful when you’ve already done the arithmetic. If the answer is that you need someone other than me, I’ll say so. You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams.

Sessions run via Zoom or in person at 30773 Milford Rd., Suite 121, New Hudson, MI 48165. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on claims and scope. This article is not tax or legal advice. Estate tax, valuation and transfer rules turn on your specific facts, and state law — including Michigan’s — differs from federal law and from other states’. Talk to your CPA and your attorney before acting on anything in the tax or valuation sections. The single testimonial above is one client’s published account of his own experience, not a measured outcome and not a claim about typical results. Every figure here is sourced below, and where no defensible published figure exists I’ve said so rather than supplying one.

Sources

All URLs accessed August 13, 2026.

Turnover, engagement and management

Hiring costs and labor turnover data

Workplace conflict

  • CPP Global Human Capital Report, Workplace Conflict and How Businesses Can Harness It to Thrive, July 2008 — 2.8 hours per week per US employee; approximately $359 billion in US paid hours in 2008; 18% saying people have left the organization because of conflict. CPP’s corporate site no longer hosts the report. I used the copy on CPP’s own content-delivery domain, img.en25.com/Web/CPP/Conflict_report.pdf, and corroborated the quoted figures against an independent reproduction hosted by JAMS Pathways; the two render the quoted sentences identically. The report is from 2008 and is flagged as dated in the text.

Tax, valuation and succession

Coaching ROI claims

  • International Coaching Federation, Coaching Statistics: The ROI of Coaching in 2024 — the PwC/ARC “seven times” figure and the FMI 87% figure, published without sample sizes, fieldwork dates or method. Cited here as an example of why I don’t repeat them as fact.

Focus Forward Coaching

  • focusforwardcoaching.com — About, Coaching, FAQ and Testimonials pages: credentials, services, the Discovery Call description, office address and phone, and the Nick Tonkin testimonial quoted verbatim.

Family Business Health Check: A Free Self-Assessment You Can Finish in Ten Minutes

Twenty-two questions, four result bands, and one instruction that matters more than your score — get a second family member to take it separately, then compare.

Last updated: August 13, 2026 · Next review: February 2027

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.

The Short Answer

Below is a scored self-assessment: 22 questions across five areas, scored 0, 1 or 2, for a maximum of 44 points. It takes about ten minutes. Higher is healthier. The four result bands at the end tell you plainly what your score means, including the band where the honest answer is that you don’t need to hire anybody — you need to write two documents and get on with running your company. Every question is here because a published governance source, a survey, or a court says it belongs. And the single most useful thing you can do with it is refuse to take it alone: have your father, your sister or your successor score it separately, without talking, and then put the two sheets side by side. The gap between the two scores tells you more than either score does.

How to Take It

Print it, or copy the questions into a document. Then:

  • Score each statement 0, 1 or 2. 0 = no, or never. 1 = partly, informally, or sometimes. 2 = yes, consistently, and it’s written down.
  • Score what is true today, not what you intend to do this year.
  • Do it alone and in one sitting. Ten minutes. No discussing, no checking with anyone.
  • Then hand it to one other person with an ownership stake or a claim on the future — a sibling, a parent, the successor — and have them score it cold.
  • Compare the totals, then compare question by question. Circle every question where you are two points apart. That short list is your actual agenda.

Answer these honestly. Nobody’s watching, and there is no version of this where flattering yourself pays.

Section 1 — Ownership and Control Clarity (5 questions, 10 points)

  1. I can state, to the percentage point, who owns what in this company today — and so can every other owner.
  2. There is a written buy-sell agreement, I could put my hands on it this week, and it has been reviewed by counsel since June 2024.
  3. It is written down what happens to shares on death, divorce, disability, or an owner who simply wants out.
  4. Owning stock and holding a job are separated in writing — a person can own without working here, and work here without owning.
  5. At least one person who is not related to us by blood or marriage sits in a formal seat where they can disagree with the owner on the record: a board of directors or a board of advisors.

Why question 2 has a date in it: in Connelly v. United States, decided June 6, 2024, the Supreme Court held that “a corporation’s contractual obligation to redeem shares is not necessarily a liability that reduces a corporation’s value for purposes of the federal estate tax.” Redemption-style buy-sell agreements funded by life insurance were widely drafted on the opposite assumption. Talk to your attorney about that one, not to me — I’m a coach, not counsel.

Section 2 — Succession Readiness (5 questions, 10 points)

  1. There is a written succession plan for who runs the company — an operating document, not a will and not an estate plan.
  2. The named successor has been told, in a direct conversation, that they are the named successor — and the people who are not have also been told.
  3. The successor helped write the plan rather than being handed it.
  4. The transition has a date attached, or a defined trigger event. “In a few years” scores 0.
  5. If the current leader were unreachable for ninety days starting tomorrow, it is written down who signs, who decides, and who calls the bank.

Why question 8 is worth as much as question 6: PwC’s Global NextGen Survey 2022 — more than a thousand next-generation family business members across 68 countries, surveyed October to December 2021 — found that “61% say the family has a succession plan and 39% of NextGens say they were involved in its development.” A plan two-thirds of successors can point to, and fewer than half helped build, is a different object than it looks like from the top.

Section 3 — How Decisions and Conflict Get Handled (4 questions, 8 points)

  1. There is a regular meeting with an agenda where business issues get raised — and family members raise the hard ones in it, rather than in the parking lot afterward.
  2. When two owners disagree and can’t resolve it, we have an agreed method for breaking the tie that doesn’t depend on who is older, louder, or angrier.
  3. In the past twelve months I have watched somebody tell the owner they were wrong, in a meeting, in front of other people, and keep their standing afterward.
  4. Our stated values set specific expectations of named family members — not general aspirations about integrity and hard work.

Why question 14 is phrased that way: PwC’s 2025 US Family Business Survey reports that “70% of US family businesses say they have a documented family vision and purpose statement” and that “over two-thirds (69%) of US family firms say they have a defined code of conduct” — but that communication of purpose “drops further when it comes to sharing within the family (53%).” Documents outnumber conversations. Score the conversation.

Section 4 — Employment Practices When the Employee Is Family (4 questions, 8 points)

  1. There is a written family employment policy stating what a family member has to do to get a job here — education, outside experience, an actual open position.
  2. Every family member employed here has a written job description, a manager who is not their parent, and a performance review that genuinely happened this year.
  3. Family compensation is set by a defined method, and I could explain any family member’s pay to a non-family employee without changing the subject.
  4. If a family member’s performance made them fireable, we would run the same process we would run for anyone else — and at some point we actually have.

Why question 15 exists at all: writing in Family Business Magazine in September 2024, Annamaria Vitelli sets out what a family employment policy contains — education requirements, a period working outside the family business, and “a resolution that the business will not hire a family member if the business does not have a legitimate job opening” — with promotions and compensation “governed by clearly defined guidelines.” Each of those is a rule you want in writing before the day you need it.

Section 5 — The Boundary Between the Business and the Dinner Table (4 questions, 8 points)

  1. There is at least one recurring family occasion where business is off the table, and the rule holds without anyone having to enforce it.
  2. Family members who own or will inherit stock but don’t work here are told what is happening in a structured way, on a schedule.
  3. No employee of this company has been used, in the past year, to carry a message between two family members who weren’t speaking.
  4. Someone has declined a business conversation at a family gathering in the past year, and nobody treated it as an insult.

Why questions 20 and 21 sit together: the family governance structures described by John Davis, writing for Harvard Business School, exist to give those conversations somewhere to go — a family assembly, and a “family council” of “a representative group of their members doing planning, creating policies, and strengthening business-family communication and bond.” Without a forum, the traffic still moves. It moves through your employees and your holidays.

Your Score Sheet

Section Questions Max Your score Their score Gap
1. Ownership and control clarity 1–5 10
2. Succession readiness 6–10 10
3. Decisions and conflict 11–14 8
4. Employment practices 15–18 8
5. Business and dinner table 19–22 8
Total 22 44

What Your Score Means

Score Band What it means What to do next
36–44 Documented and aligned You have the documents, the forums and the conversations. Whatever is bothering you is more likely an operating problem than a family one. You do not need to hire anyone right now. Diarize a review of the buy-sell and the succession plan for twelve months out, add succession to a board or family council agenda annually, and go run your company. If something still feels wrong, get a second family member’s sheet before you spend a dollar.
25–35 Working, but held in people’s heads It functions, and it functions because specific people are reasonable. Take one of those people out — illness, a divorce, a bad quarter — and the mechanism is gone. Convert two things from understanding into writing this quarter: the family employment policy and the ninety-day continuity note (question 10). Both are short. Neither needs a consultant.
14–24 Running on goodwill The structure isn’t holding the relationships; the relationships are holding the structure. This is where most family businesses I meet actually score, and it is not a moral failing. Pick the lowest-scoring section and fix that one only. If it’s Section 1 or 2, that’s your attorney and your CPA. If it’s Section 3, 4 or 5, more documents won’t help — the missing item is a conversation somebody has to be willing to start.
0–13 One event away Ownership, succession and employment are all undefined at once. A death, a divorce, a serious illness or one genuinely bad year turns an unwritten arrangement into a dispute among people who love each other. Don’t try to fix five sections. Get the ownership documents current first — that is legal work — and get a neutral third party into the room for the succession and employment conversations, because the reason they haven’t happened is not that nobody has thought of them.

The Part Most People Miss

Most articles that hand you a self-assessment stop at the score. Take the test, read your band, act accordingly. True enough, and it quietly assumes the thing that is least true in a family company: that one person’s answers describe the business.

They don’t. They describe that person’s model of the business. And in a family firm, the number that predicts trouble is not how dysfunctional the company is in absolute terms. It’s how far apart two people who own the same company are when you ask them the same question.

You don’t have to take that on faith. PwC has asked the same questions of both generations and published both answers. In its Global NextGen Survey 2022, “a similarly high percentage of NextGens (76%) believes their business is actively contributing to the community, again compared to just over half (54%) of the current generation.” On climate responsibility, “only half of the current generation believe their business has a responsibility to fight climate change and its consequences, compared to the nearly three-quarters of NextGens.”

Now look at what didn’t diverge. On the same survey: “Similar percentages, 42% of NextGens and 38% of the current generation believe their business has strong digital capabilities.”

That is the finding, and almost nobody says it out loud. On the countable question — do we have good systems — the two generations are four points apart. On the questions about purpose and what the business is for, they are twenty-two and twenty-five points apart. Two people can walk the same building every day, agree completely about the software, and be describing two different companies the moment you ask what it’s supposed to mean.

Which is why an assessment scored by one person is a survey with a sample size of one. And it is why question 8 carries the same weight as question 6. Sixty-one percent of next-generation members say a succession plan exists; thirty-nine percent say they helped develop it. If your successor scores question 6 a 2 and question 8 a 0, you don’t have a readiness problem. You have a plan that was described to somebody rather than agreed with them.

A plan only one person can describe isn’t a plan. It’s a private intention with a filing cabinet.

So: score it, then get the second sheet. Where the two of you are two points apart, don’t argue about who scored it correctly. Neither of you did. The gap is the finding, and it is the only part of this assessment that you could not have produced on your own.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

A low score means my family is dysfunctional, doesn’t it?

No. It usually means you are a company that grew faster than its paperwork, which is what happens when the founders are competent and get along. Most of the families I work with are functioning well enough that a real problem has survived a decade without anyone forcing it — that takes skill, not dysfunction. The score measures documentation and forums, not affection.

There are four of us and we all get along. Do we honestly need written policies?

While everyone is healthy, present and reasonable, no — and I’m not going to pretend otherwise to sell you something. The documents aren’t for the version of your family that exists on a good Tuesday. They’re for the version that exists nine months after a funeral, when a spouse who has never worked here inherits stock and has a lawyer. That’s the entire argument for Section 1.

What if my father won’t take it?

That is a data point, and it is worth more than a completed sheet. Try asking for one section rather than all five — Section 2 is usually the one he’ll engage with, because it’s the one he’s already thinking about. If the refusal is flat, don’t push it into a fight. Score it yourself, note that you couldn’t get a second sheet, and treat that as the finding.

Deloitte, PwC — those surveys are of enormous companies. Does any of this apply to us?

Partly, and I’d rather say so than let a number do work it can’t. Deloitte Private’s 2025 survey of 300 family business executives found that “61% of surveyed family businesses report at least one family member interested in the CEO role” while “fewer than a quarter (23%) believe those individuals are ready to assume the position in the near term” — but those were substantially larger firms than most family businesses. Read that as a pattern worth checking against yourself, not a benchmark you have to hit.

Can I send you my results?

You can, and you don’t have to. If the two sheets are close and both scores are high, you have your answer and you don’t need a call. If they’re far apart, bring both sheets to a Discovery Call and we’ll look at the gaps rather than the totals.

Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct with you, because that’s what I would want.

If your low scores are all in Section 1 — ownership percentages, buy-sell agreements, what happens to shares on a divorce — I am not the person for that. That is legal and tax work, your attorney and your CPA do it, and it should be current before anyone talks to me. I’ll say so on the call rather than after the invoice.

Where I do fit is the part of this assessment that no document fixes:

  • Credentials in the underlying discipline. MLIR — a master’s degree in human resources from Michigan State University — and SPHR, the Senior Professional in Human Resources certification.
  • Thirty years of these specific rooms. More than 30 years working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits, and 25-plus years as owner of Focus Forward Coaching. Family business strategy is a stated core specialty, including the transition from the Now Generation to the Next Gen.
  • A structured way to find out what people actually think. My team assessments start with an interview-style survey of employees in a space where they can speak openly, and end in a Report of Findings pairing each identified issue with a prescribed action — the multi-person version of what two score sheets do for two people.
  • Facilitated difficult conversations and conflict resolution, which is what Sections 3, 4 and 5 become once the gaps are visible.
  • Fluent in operating systems without selling one. I’ve coached leaders and teams running on EOS for more than 25 years. I am not an EOS Implementer.
  • On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity, and featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call. It’s a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what’s really going on in your business or leadership. Bring both score sheets if you have them. If the answer is that you need an attorney and a weekend with a printer rather than a coach, I’ll tell you that.

You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams. Sessions run via Zoom or in person in New Hudson, Michigan. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on two claims. This assessment is not a validated psychometric instrument. The questions come from published governance practice and survey findings; the score bands are my professional judgment about what the answers mean, not a measured statistic. And the observation that two family members almost never score this the same way is my own account of thirty years of doing the work. PwC’s generational figures above show that divergence exists on identical questions — that is evidence for the pattern, not proof of it in your company. Nothing here is legal, tax or financial advice. Every figure and quotation is sourced below.

Sources

All URLs accessed August 13, 2026.

Family business survey data

  • PwC, 2025 US Family Business Survey — 70% with a documented family vision and purpose statement; 69% with a defined code of conduct; communication of purpose within the family at 53%; 44% citing succession planning impacts in the past year.
  • PwC, Global NextGen Survey 2022 press release — the generational comparisons on community contribution (76% vs 54%), climate responsibility, and digital capabilities (42% vs 38%); “61% say the family has a succession plan and 39% of NextGens say they were involved in its development”; more than one thousand NextGen members across 68 countries, surveyed 8 October – 12 December 2021.
  • PwC, Global NextGen Survey 2024 — 917 respondents across 63 territories, November 2023 – January 2024; consulted for the current edition of the NextGen series.
  • Deloitte, Deloitte Private survey reveals family businesses are facing a succession paradox — 300 family business executives, surveyed September 2025; 61% with a family member interested in the CEO role vs 23% believed ready in the near term. Larger firms than most family businesses; cited with that caveat.

Governance structures

  • John Davis, The Three Components of Family Governance, Harvard Business School Working Knowledge — definitions of the family assembly, family council and family constitution.
  • FamilyBusiness.org, How to Govern a Family Business, published in partnership with the Schulze School of Entrepreneurship, University of St. Thomas — the role of an independent board and of written family employment policies established before they are needed.
  • Annamaria Vitelli, Employment policies: A critical step in family governance, Family Business Magazine, September 23, 2024 — the contents of a family employment policy.
  • PwC, Family business governance — family/owner council and family employment policy as family-level governance elements; board of directors as a formal method for governing and controlling the business.

Ownership documents

  • Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. ___ (2024), Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center — decided June 6, 2024; holding that a corporation’s contractual obligation to redeem shares is not necessarily a liability that reduces the corporation’s value for federal estate tax purposes.

Focus Forward Coaching

  • About — MLIR from Michigan State University, SPHR, 30+ years, firm launched over 25 years ago.
  • Coaching and services — family business strategy as a core specialty; team assessment and Report of Findings; facilitated conversations; transition planning.
  • FAQ — the Discovery Call; 25+ years coaching leaders and teams running on EOS; Zoom or New Hudson, Michigan.

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights