Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Focus Forward

What If Coaching Doesn’t Work? Fit, Guarantees, and How We Decide Together

There is no guarantee. Here is what I will promise instead, where the work can honestly stop, and the six situations where I will tell you on the first call that you need somebody else.

Last updated: August 13, 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.

I don’t offer a guarantee, and you should be suspicious of anyone who does. No coach can promise you a business result, because the result depends on decisions your family makes after I leave the room. What I can promise is the process, the confidentiality terms, the written work product, and that I will tell you when you need a different professional — including when that professional is not me. Coaching works when three things are true: the owner participates instead of sending everyone else, the person paying is willing to hear findings about themselves, and there is a decision the family is actually willing to make. When one of those is missing, the engagement doesn’t fail dramatically. It just quietly doesn’t change anything, and you paid for it.

This is the one article on this site where I am not going to hand you a testimonial. It would be beside the point.

What Has to Be True for This to Work

Fit isn’t about whether we like each other on the call. It’s about whether the conditions exist for anything to change. Four of them matter more than the rest.

  • The owner is in the room. The most common wasted engagement is an owner who hires me to fix the team and then doesn’t attend. In a family company the owner is usually part of the pattern, and a pattern can’t be worked on by proxy.
  • The person paying is willing to hear findings about themselves. My Team Assessment starts with an interview-style survey of employees and produces a Report of Findings — identified issues with specific actions prescribed. Some of those findings will be about you. If you already know which answers you’ll accept, you’re buying a document, not a diagnosis.
  • There is a decision the family is actually willing to make. Not willing to discuss. Willing to make. Who runs the company, who owns what, whether your brother keeps the title, whether the business gets sold. If every real option is off the table before we start, the conversation has nowhere to go.
  • The people in the conflict will attend. If the person at the center of it won’t join a call, there’s no conversation to facilitate — only me relaying messages, which is what you already have.

None of these are commitments you make to me. They’re commitments to the outcome you say you want. I’d rather find out on a free call that one is missing than four months in.

The Six Situations Where I’ll Tell You Coaching Is the Wrong Tool

These come up more often than you’d think, and I will say so on the Discovery Call rather than after the invoice.

  • There’s an active legal dispute between owners. If shareholders are in litigation or heading there, you need counsel first. Anything said in a facilitated room while a case is live can complicate the case.
  • Somebody suspects fraud, theft, or a compliance problem. That is an investigation, not a conversation. It needs an attorney and likely a forensic accountant.
  • There is active addiction or untreated mental illness in a key person. Coaching is not clinical treatment, and I am not a clinician. Michigan licenses counselors, psychologists, marriage and family therapists and social workers; a business coach is not one of them. When what’s in front of me is a health issue, the referral goes to someone licensed to treat it, and the business conversation waits.
  • The decision is already made. If you’ve decided to sell, or to transfer ownership to one child, and everyone knows it, you need an attorney and a term sheet, not me. I can help with how it gets communicated — but that’s a smaller job than what people usually call about, and I’ll say so.
  • A necessary party won’t participate. If your father will not join, the honest answer is that we can work on you. That’s a real engagement, but it isn’t the one you called about.
  • What you actually need is an operating system. If the company has no meeting rhythm, no scorecard and no clear accountabilities, that’s an implementation job, and an EOS Implementer will do it better and faster than I will. I refer that work out without argument.

What I Will Promise, and What I Won’t

What you might want promised Can it honestly be promised? What you get instead
A specific business outcome — revenue, a closed sale, a completed transition No. It depends on decisions made after the session ends A clear finding, the options on the table, and the conversation in which the decision gets made
That a family member changes their behavior No. Nobody can promise you another adult’s behavior A conversation in which the behavior is named out loud, in front of the people it affects, with a commitment attached
A timeline — “resolved in 90 days” No. The pace is set by how fast your family will move Sessions with action steps between them, and a check-in on whether it’s still worth continuing
Confidentiality of what employees say Partly — know the limits. The assessment exists to be reported, and in a ten-person company some findings are traceable however carefully they’re written Interviews in a space where people can share openly, and findings written as issues and actions rather than as a transcript of who said what
A written Report of Findings Yes. A defined deliverable Identified issues with specific actions prescribed — a customized roadmap you keep whether or not we work together further
Being told when you need a different professional Yes. The promise I make most often A named referral on the Discovery Call — attorney, clinician, EOS Implementer — before you’ve spent anything
A refund if you’re unhappy Not as a published policy. I don’t publish one, and most coaches don’t Ask any advisor, including me, for the payment and cancellation terms in writing before you sign. If they won’t put it in writing, that’s your answer

Where This Can Honestly Stop

An engagement that can’t end is a subscription, not a service. There are three natural places to stop, and stopping at any of them is a normal outcome rather than a failure.

After the Discovery Call. It’s free, and it’s a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what’s really going on in your business or leadership. Plenty of them end with me pointing somewhere else. You leave with clarity on next steps either way.

After the Report of Findings. Some owners read the findings, recognize the problem and handle it themselves. That is a legitimate ending. You bought a diagnosis; you’re allowed to do the treatment yourself.

After the first facilitated conversation. Sometimes one conversation is the whole job. Sometimes it reveals that the parties aren’t willing, and continuing would be selling hope. Either way it’s a clean place to stop, and I’ll say which one I think it is.

What “It Didn’t Work” Usually Turns Out to Mean

When I follow up on an engagement that didn’t produce change, it is almost never that the finding was wrong. The finding is usually accepted — sometimes with visible relief that somebody finally said it. What didn’t happen is the decision. The father who agreed his son needed real authority signed nothing giving him any. The siblings who agreed the compensation was unfair went home and left it unfair. Everyone understood. Nobody moved.

That’s worth knowing before you hire anyone, because it tells you what to buy. If your family already knows what’s wrong and won’t act, another assessment will not help you. What you need is a facilitated conversation that ends in a written commitment with a date on it — and someone willing to ask, in the room, what happens if it doesn’t get done.

About the “100% Success” Line on My Own Website

My Coaching page says this, under both Communication Consulting & Conflict Resolution and Business Transition / Transfer Planning: “I’ve facilitated conversations for 30 years w/ 100% success!”

That is Focus Forward Coaching’s own published claim on its own site. It is not an independently audited figure, nobody outside my practice counted it, and you should read it the way you’d read any vendor’s self-reported number.

Here’s what it can mean and what it can’t. Success in a facilitated difficult conversation means the participants got through it — they said the thing, they understood each other, and they left with commitments. It does not mean every business outcome that followed was good, or that every commitment made in the room survived the next quarter. Those are different measurements, and I don’t have them.

Use that as a test on anybody, not just on me. When an advisor quotes a success rate, ask three things: what counted as a success, who counted it, and what happened to the cases that didn’t finish? An honest answer sounds specific and a little smaller than the headline. A vague answer tells you the number was written by marketing. Federal advertising rules point the same way — where an ad features a customer’s results, the FTC’s endorsement guides say “an advertiser should possess and rely upon adequate substantiation” that the experience represents what customers generally achieve (16 CFR 255.2(b)). A number nobody can substantiate is a slogan.

The Part Most People Miss

Most articles about choosing a coach stop at “look for credentials and chemistry.” True, and not much use when everyone you’re interviewing has both. Here’s what almost nobody explains: outcome guarantees are nearly absent from serious coaching for structural reasons, and those reasons tell you how to shop.

The professional standard forbids the claim, not just the failure. The International Coaching Federation’s Code of Ethics requires an ICF professional to “make verbal and written statements that are true and accurate about what I offer as an ICF professional, what is offered by ICF, the coaching profession, and the potential value of coaching” (Standard 5.2), and to “accurately identify my coaching qualifications and work within the boundaries of my level of coaching competency” (Standard 5.1). Standard 1.1 requires a coach to explain the nature of coaching before it begins and co-create an agreement covering “roles, responsibilities, confidentiality, financial arrangements, and other aspects of the coaching engagement.” Read together, that’s the shape of an honest promise: the agreement, the boundaries, the accurate description. Not the result.

But nothing forces anyone to follow it. ICF is a membership organization. Its ethics process reaches “ICF members and credential-holders,” and its heaviest sanction is that a coach who refuses the findings “will automatically lose their membership or credential.” Real consequence — not a license. Michigan’s Bureau of Professional Licensing licenses occupations from accountancy and architecture to barbering, collection agencies and real estate, and separately licenses health professions including counseling, psychology, marriage and family therapy and social work. Business coach appears on neither list. Anyone in this state can print the title on a card tomorrow.

Which is why regulators, not licensing boards, are the ones who show up. In September 2023 the FTC sued the online business-coaching operation Lurn and its CEO over deceptive earnings claims, alleging the company “had no information to back up these claims.” Where the Business Opportunity Rule applies (16 CFR Part 437), the FTC’s guidance is blunt: “it’s illegal to make an earnings claim unless you have written materials on hand that back up what you’re saying,” and the claim has to come with a separate document headed “EARNINGS CLAIM STATEMENT REQUIRED BY LAW.” On January 13, 2025 the FTC proposed extending that rule to money-making opportunities including business coaching. Those remain proposals; I could find no final rule.

Put the three facts side by side. The ethical standard that prohibits over-promising binds only volunteers. The occupational license that would give it teeth doesn’t exist. The enforcement that does exist arrives years later, after the money is gone.

So when a coach guarantees your results, you’re not hearing confidence. You’re hearing someone who has correctly worked out that nothing happens to them.

What a coach can honestly promise: the process; the confidentiality terms, including their limits; the written artifacts you keep; the payment and cancellation terms in writing; a defined point where you can stop; and that they’ll tell you when you need someone else.

What nobody can honestly promise: that your brother will change; that the deal will close; a revenue number; a date by which your family will be at peace; or that the person who has avoided this conversation for a decade will show up for it because you paid a professional.

A guarantee is not a measure of how good the coach is. It’s a measure of how little happens to them if it turns out not to be true.

Is This the Right Moment for Coaching?

Answer these honestly. Nobody’s watching, and there’s no score.

  1. Am I willing to be in the room for this myself, not just to authorize it?
  2. If the findings say part of the problem is how I lead, will I still pay the invoice and keep going?
  3. Is there at least one real decision my family is prepared to make in the next six months?
  4. Will the person at the center of this actually attend?
  5. Have I told the other people involved that this is happening, or am I planning to spring it on them?
  6. If someone told me today that what I need is a lawyer, a clinician, or an EOS Implementer instead — would I be relieved, or annoyed?

If you hesitated on more than two, that’s not a reason to avoid the call. It’s the material for the call. Bring the hesitation with you; it’s usually the most honest thing in the conversation.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

Does business coaching actually work?

For some situations, reliably. For others, not at all — and the difference is mostly fit rather than the coach. Facilitated conversation works when the parties will attend and the family is willing to decide something. It is not a substitute for legal advice, clinical treatment, an investigation, or an operating system. Anyone who tells you it works for everything is describing their invoicing, not their results.

Do you offer a money-back guarantee?

No, and I don’t publish a refund policy. I’d rather be judged on the free Discovery Call and on whether the Report of Findings is accurate. With me and with anyone else: ask for the payment and cancellation terms in writing before you sign.

What does it cost?

I don’t publish prices; the work varies enormously between an individual leadership engagement and a full team assessment with facilitated conversations. It’s settled on the call, with terms in writing. If cost is your first question, ask it first — it’s fair, and it saves us both time.

What if we start and it isn’t working?

Say so, and we stop at the next exit point. If we’re past all three and it still isn’t moving, in my experience the block is an unmade decision rather than a missing insight — and I’ll tell you that rather than sell you more sessions.

Isn’t “no guarantee” just a way to protect yourself?

It protects you more than it protects me. A guarantee would require me to control your family’s decisions, and any coach who could control your family’s decisions is doing something you should not want done to your family. What I can be held to is whether the process ran as described and whether the findings were accurate. Those you can check.

Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct, because that’s what I’d want. I’m not an EOS Implementer and not part of the EOS franchise. I’m not an attorney and not a licensed clinician. If your situation needs one of those first, that’s what I’ll tell you on the free call, before you’ve spent anything.

  • Credentials. MLIR and a master’s in Human Resources from Michigan State University, plus SPHR — Certified Senior Human Resource Professional.
  • Experience. More than 30 years with passionate leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits. Focus Forward Coaching launched over 25 years ago.
  • Specialty. Family business strategy is a core specialty — challenging family dynamics, and the transition from the Now Generation to the Next Gen.
  • EOS fluency without EOS affiliation. I’ve coached leaders and teams running on the Entrepreneurial Operating System for more than 25 years, and I work alongside Implementers rather than against them.
  • On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity, and featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call. It’s free, and it’s a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what’s really going on in your business or leadership. If the answer is that you need someone other than me — a lawyer, a clinician, an Implementer, or nobody at all yet — I’ll say so on that call. You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams. Sessions run via Zoom, or in person at 30773 Milford Rd., Suite 121, New Hudson, MI 48165. Call 248-973-7595.

A Note on Claims

One statement here is my own account of my practice rather than published data: the pattern under “What ‘It Didn’t Work’ Usually Turns Out to Mean” — that stalled engagements are blocked by an unmade decision rather than a rejected finding. That’s thirty years of observation, not a study. The “100% success” line is Focus Forward Coaching’s own published claim on its own website, identified as such above and not offered as an independent finding. Every other figure, rule and quotation is sourced below.

Sources

All URLs accessed August 13, 2026.

Coaching ethics and standards

Licensing

Federal advertising and earnings-claim rules

Focus Forward Coaching

  • Coaching services — the service list, the Team Assessment and Report of Findings, and the “100% success” line quoted verbatim.
  • FAQ — the free Discovery Call; no published pricing, refund policy or guarantee.

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights