You think you are trying to win a vote. What actually produces agreement is a page about confidentiality and money, written before anyone is asked to say yes.
Last updated: 13 August 2026
By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.
The Short Answer
Stop trying to get everyone to agree, and start answering the questions they have not asked out loud. In my experience the resistant family member is almost never objecting to coaching. They are objecting to not knowing who pays, who the coach reports to, what gets repeated, and whether they can stop.
Those four questions have professional answers that predate your family, and the standard is that they get settled in writing before the first session. Do that, offer everyone an exit, and start with whoever is willing — because the research on what makes coaching work says the one thing you cannot install from the outside is another person’s willingness.
Who Is the Client? The Question Underneath All the Others
In a family business, the person paying and the person being coached are frequently not the same person. A father funds coaching for a successor. Two siblings split the fee for a facilitated conversation. The company writes the cheque and one leader sits in the chair.
The coaching profession has language for this. The ICF Code of Ethics defines the client as “the individual, team, or group member being coached,” and the sponsor as “the entity (including its representatives) or individual paying for and/or arranging or defining the coaching services to be provided.”
Two different roles. In your family they may be your brother and you. If nobody has said out loud which is which, every other question in this article stays unanswerable — and your brother is right to be wary.
The Four Answers a Reluctant Family Member Actually Wants
Not “why coaching is valuable.” These.
| The question they will not ask | What it means in a family business | Who has to answer it, and when |
|---|---|---|
| Who is the client — me, or the person paying? | If your father pays for your coaching, is he entitled to know how it is going? | The coach, in writing, before session one |
| Who hears what I say? | Whether a private session becomes dinner-table material, or a line in a report | The coach and the sponsor, agreed jointly, before session one |
| Can I stop? | Whether saying yes once means being committed indefinitely | The person proposing it, out loud, in the first conversation |
| What happens if the coach and I disagree about what the problem is? | Whether the outcome is already decided and this is theatre | The coach, by describing what they will not do |
The reason those go unanswered is that the person organising it is usually so relieved to have got a yes that they do not want to introduce complications. That is exactly backwards. The complications are the reassurance.
The professional standard is unambiguous about the timing. The ICF Code of Ethics requires a coach to “Communicate (before coaching begins) with coaching client(s), sponsor(s), and/or other involved parties that the coach is in a direct relationship with to explain the nature of coaching and to co-create a coaching agreement regarding roles, responsibilities, confidentiality, financial arrangements, and other aspects of the coaching engagement,” and separately to “Have a clear agreement about what information is exchanged and how it is exchanged among all parties involved during all coaching engagements.” The Global Code of Ethics — the joint code adopted by EMCC Global, the Association for Coaching and ten other bodies, now in its fourth version — sets the same expectation, requiring members to establish with both client and sponsor, before the work starts, what the nature, terms and conditions of the engagement are.
Note the parenthesis in the ICF clause: before coaching begins. Not in session three when it becomes awkward. Before.
And there is a clause most people never hear about that does more for buy-in than any argument: coaches must “Respect all parties’ right to terminate the coaching relationship at any point for any reason during the coaching engagement, subject to the provisions of the agreement.” Say that sentence to your reluctant sibling in the first conversation. In my experience it unlocks more yeses than any case for the value of coaching ever has.
Nobody resists a conversation. They resist not knowing who is going to hear it.
The Part Most People Miss: The Person Refusing Is at a Documented Stage, and Arguing Harder Is the Wrong Move for It
Here is the reframe that changes how you approach this.
Prochaska and Velicer’s transtheoretical model — one of the most-used frameworks in behaviour change research — describes five stages people move through. The first is precontemplation, defined as “the stage in which people are not intending to take action in the foreseeable future, usually measured as the next 6 months.” Then contemplation: “intending to change in the next 6 months.” Then preparation: “intending to take action in the immediate future, usually measured as the next month.” Then action, then maintenance.
The sentence that matters for your family is this one, from the authors themselves:
“They are often characterized in other theories as resistant or unmotivated clients or as not ready for therapy or health promotion programs.”
Your father is not being difficult. He is at a stage — a named, described, ordinary stage — and the intervention that moves someone from precontemplation to contemplation is not the same intervention that works on someone already in preparation. Arguing the merits of coaching to a person in precontemplation is answering a question they have not asked. It reliably produces the compliant yes, which is worse than a no because it wastes six months before anyone admits it.
Now put that beside what actually predicts whether coaching works. De Haan, Grant, Burger and Eriksson studied 1,895 client–coach pairs across 366 coaches in 34 countries. Their finding: “the strength of this working alliance—particularly as seen through the eyes of the coachee—is a key ingredient” in coaching effectiveness. They also found that coach and coachee personality, and personality matching between them, were unrelated to effectiveness.
Sit with what those two findings do together.
The active ingredient is a relationship as experienced by the person being coached. You cannot form that on their behalf. You cannot recruit it, negotiate it, or buy it for them. Which means the goal of your buy-in effort is not to secure a yes — a yes you extracted is precisely the yes that produces no alliance and therefore no result. The goal is to remove the reasons a person would say no to something they might otherwise want.
And notice what the same research kills off: the argument families spend weeks on. “He’d never get on with someone like that.” Personality matching was unrelated to effectiveness. You are litigating a variable that does not predict the outcome, while ignoring the ones that do.
Why the Vacuum Exists in the First Place
There is a reason bringing in a coach feels like an ambush to some family members, and it is not about coaching.
In a survey conducted by the Smith Family Business Initiative at Cornell University with Family Enterprise USA and The Roberts Group, 164 next-generation family business students were asked about their families’ governance. Nearly half reported having no family council. Forty-five percent reported no family constitution, employment policy or formal board. Treat that carefully — these are students describing their own families, not audited records of operating companies. But the direction is the useful part: a substantial share of the rising generation cannot point to any agreed rule about how their family makes decisions together.
If nothing has ever been agreed, then every new proposal — a coach, an outside board member, a written policy — arrives as a unilateral act by whoever proposed it. It is not the coaching people are resisting. It is being the last to know, again.
Which is why the contracting conversation is worth more than the pitch. For many families, the agreement about confidentiality and roles is the first thing they have ever written down together about how they will handle something difficult. That is not a preliminary to the work. It is the work, starting early.
Run the Invitation Like This
Concretely, in order.
- Talk to each person one at a time, before anyone hears it as a group decision. Ask what they think the problem is. Do not lead with your answer.
- Bring the four questions from the table, and say you do not yet know the answers. You are not selling. You are collecting the terms.
- Choose the coach together, or at least let everyone veto. A coach chosen solely by the person with the most power is “Dad’s coach” for the entire engagement, and everybody in the room will behave accordingly.
- Have the coach explain confidentiality directly to each family member — not you relaying it. Second-hand assurances about confidentiality are worth nothing, and reasonably so.
- Offer the exit explicitly. Any party can stop, at any point, for any reason.
- Start with whoever is willing. Not with everyone.
That last point is the one people resist and it is the most important. A holdout does not have to become a supporter for useful work to begin — they only have to not be a target of it. Coaching that starts with two willing people and produces a visible result is the most persuasive thing that will ever happen to the third.
Two exceptions, and I would say both on a first call. Do not start a facilitated conversation without both parties agreeing — that is not coaching, it is an ambush with a witness. And do not start anything if participation is being used as leverage over someone’s job or their shares.
A Consent Check, One Row Per Person
Write the names down the side. Answer honestly for each — including yourself.
- Do they know why this is being proposed, in words that are not a criticism of them?
- Were they asked before it was decided, or told after?
- Do they know who is paying, and what the payer will and will not receive?
- Have they heard the confidentiality terms from the coach directly?
- Do they know how to stop it, and do they believe there would be no consequence for doing so?
- Did they have any say in who the coach is?
- If they said yes, do you believe it — or did they say yes to end the conversation?
How to read it. Any row with three or more noes is a person who will attend and not participate, and you will pay full price for it. Row 5 is the one that most often fails silently: if stopping would cost someone their standing in the family, they do not really have an exit, and they know it. Row 7 is the one to be bravest about. A compliant yes from a person in precontemplation is not buy-in — it is a delay with a fee attached. Better to hear the no now and start with the people who mean it.
And if every row comes back clean for everyone: you did not need this article. Go and book it.
Questions Leaders Ask Me About This
One sibling flatly refuses. Can we start anyway?
Usually yes, with one condition: nothing in the early work should be about them. Start where the willing people are — the two of you who can work together, or the leadership issue that does not require them. What changes minds is not being persuaded, it is watching something improve and not being blamed for it. What does not work is starting a facilitated conversation between two people when only one has agreed to it.
I’m paying for it. Am I entitled to know how it’s going?
To something, yes — and it should be defined before you pay. Reasonable and common: confirmation of attendance, and progress against goals that were agreed with everyone in the room at the start. Not reasonable, and I would decline it: an account of what was said. The ICF code requires the agreement about information exchange to be clear and made with all parties. If you want more than that, ask for it openly at the start so the person being coached can decide whether to accept those terms, rather than discovering them later.
Can one coach work with all of us?
It is permitted and it is common, but it has to be handled explicitly. The ICF code requires a coach to “Am aware of and discuss with all involved parties the implications of having multiple agreements and relationships, and the potential for conflicts of interest,” and to resolve a conflict by “working through the issue with relevant parties, seeking professional assistance, or suspending or ending the professional relationship.” The Global Code of Ethics adds a duty to consider how one client relationship affects another and to discuss any potential conflict openly. What that looks like in practice: the coach names the risk in the first meeting rather than waiting for it to arrive, and everyone knows in advance what happens if the coach has to step back from one of the relationships.
Should we all choose the coach together?
If you can, yes — and treat the selection itself as the first piece of family governance you have done together. It is a low-stakes decision with a real outcome, which makes it excellent practice. It also removes the single most corrosive dynamic in family coaching, which is one person believing the coach was hired to deliver a verdict they already agreed with.
What if someone says yes just to keep the peace?
Assume some of them will, and design for it. Give it a defined, short first block with a decision point at the end, rather than an open-ended commitment. Make the exit real and say so twice. And ask the coach, directly, in front of everyone: what will you do if you think one of us is here under duress? The answer tells you a great deal about who you are hiring.
Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not
Let me be direct with you, because that is what I would want. I will not take an engagement where one family member has been signed up without being asked, and I will say so on the first call rather than after the invoice. Not on principle alone — because the research says it will not work, and I would rather lose the engagement than take money for something with a poor chance of producing a result.
- The credentials behind the work. Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR. A master’s degree from Michigan State University, one of the top human resource programs in the country, and certification as a Senior Professional in Human Resources.
- Thirty years in the relationship layer. More than 30 years working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits, and a practice launched more than 25 years ago.
- The contracting conversation happens first, with everyone. Before any coaching begins, we settle who the client is, who the sponsor is, what is confidential, what is reported and how anyone stops. In writing.
- A safe space is a method, not a promise. Team assessments begin with an interview-style survey of your employees in a safe space where they can share openly, and produce a Report of Findings that pairs every issue with a prescribed action to correct it — your customised roadmap.
- Fluent in EOS without selling it. I have coached leaders and teams running on the Entrepreneurial Operating System for more than 25 years.
- Endorsed by the man who built EOS. Gino Wickman, creator of EOS and author of Traction and Get A Grip: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.”
- On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity, and featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.
Where to start. Schedule a Discovery Call — and if it helps, invite the family member who is least keen. It is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation, they can ask me the confidentiality question directly, and if the answer is that this is not the right time for your family, I will say so. Sessions run via Zoom or in person in New Hudson, Michigan. Call 248-973-7595. You are closer than you realise to the business and team of your dreams.
A note on claims: the recommendation to start with willing participants, and the invitation sequence above, are my own practice judgement rather than published findings — they are informed by the research cited below but are not themselves conclusions of it. Every figure and quotation in this article is sourced.
Sources
All URLs accessed 13 August 2026.
Professional standards on contracting and confidentiality
International Coaching Federation, ICF Code of Ethics (current Code effective 1 April 2025) — sections 1.1 and 1.2 on agreements and the right to terminate; 2.1–2.3 on confidentiality and information exchange; 3.1–3.3 on multiple relationships and conflicts of interest; definitions of Client and Sponsor https://coachingfederation.org/credentialing/coaching-ethics/icf-code-of-ethics/ · ICF Code of Ethics PDF https://coachingfederation.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/icf-ethics-code-of-ethics-2025.pdf · The Global Code of Ethics for Coaches, Mentors and Supervisors, Version 4 (updated December 2025) — the joint code of EMCC Global, the Association for Coaching and ten other signatory bodies; contracting, confidentiality and conflict-of-interest provisions https://www.globalcodeofethics.org/ · EMCC Global, on the publication of the current version of the Global Code of Ethics https://emccglobal.org/news/global-code-of-ethics-new-version/
Readiness to change and what predicts coaching outcomes
Prochaska & Velicer (1997), “The Transtheoretical Model of Health Behavior Change,” American Journal of Health Promotion 12(1), 38–48 — stage definitions and the characterisation of precontemplators as “resistant or unmotivated clients” https://sdlab.fas.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum5291/files/sdlab/files/prochaska_1997_transtheoretical_model_of_health_behaviour_change.pdf · de Haan, Grant, Burger & Eriksson (2016), “A large-scale study of executive and workplace coaching: The relative contributions of relationship, personality match, and self-efficacy,” Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research 68(3), 189–207 — 1,895 client–coach pairs; the working alliance as seen by the coachee, and the null result for personality matching https://www.yvonneburger.nl/files/artikel_de_haan,_grant,_burger,_eriksson3427.pdf · Spence & Oades (2011), “Coaching with self-determination in mind: Using theory to advance evidence-based coaching practice,” International Journal of Evidence Based Coaching and Mentoring 9(2) — autonomy, competence and relatedness as the framework for coaching practice https://instituteofcoaching.org/resources/coaching-self-determination-mind-using-theory-advance-evidence-based-coaching-practice
Family business governance
Smith Family Business Initiative at Cornell University, Family Enterprise USA and The Roberts Group, 2024-25 Family Business Rising Gen Survey — 164 next-generation respondents; family council and governance-document findings https://familyenterpriseusa.com/feusa/2024-25-family-business-rising-gen-survey-communication-is-still-key/ · Family Enterprise USA, 2025 Annual Family Business Survey — 730 respondents from 45 states, fielded January and February 2025 https://familyenterpriseusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/2025.FEUSA-Survey.-Executive-Summary.Final_.v.2.1.pdf
Focus Forward Coaching
Home https://focusforwardcoaching.com/ · About https://focusforwardcoaching.com/about/ · Services https://focusforwardcoaching.com/services/ · FAQ https://focusforwardcoaching.com/faq/ · Testimonials https://focusforwardcoaching.com/testimonials/ · Contact https://focusforwardcoaching.com/contact/