Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Communication · Focus Forward

How to Resolve Conflict Between Family Members Who Work Together: Start by Working Out Which Argument You’re Actually Having

Most family business fights are two arguments stacked on top of each other, and you can’t settle the one on top until somebody names the one underneath.

Last updated: August 13, 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MHRLR, SPHR , Focus Forward Coaching, Milford, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.

Separate the business disagreement from the family argument, and resolve them in different rooms. Family firm research splits conflict into three kinds; task, process and relationship. The first two can make a company better. The third reliably damages it, and in a family business it almost always arrives dressed as one of the other two, because the business version is the only one anyone will schedule a meeting about.

So the sequence matters more than the technique. Go in this order: a direct private conversation, then a structured conversation with an agenda and ground rules, then a standing family forum, then an outside neutral. Skip a step and you pay to solve the wrong layer. And before any of it, check whether you have a conflict at all; a large share of this turns out to be two people who were never told where one job ends and the other begins.

First: Which Argument Are You Actually Having?

Family business research borrows a three-part split from organizational psychology, and it is the most useful thing you can learn about your own company. Writing for IMD in August 2025, Alfredo De Massis, co-author of a 2025 framework paper on family business conflict in the Journal of Family Business Strategy, describes all three:

  • Task conflict. Disagreement about what to do: pricing, hiring, the second location. It “can improve decision-making by generating new insights,” though it slows decisions down. This is the productive kind.
  • Process conflict. Disagreement about how the work gets done and who does it. Also potentially useful, it forces a family to evaluate approaches instead of defaulting to habit.
  • Relationship conflict. De Massis defines it as “an awareness of interpersonal incompatibilities” that fosters “tension and friction,” along with “resentment, aversion, and hostility.” This is the one that does the damage.

In a family company they don’t stay in their lanes. Kellermanns and Eddleston’s 2004 study in Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, Feuding Families: When Conflict Does a Family Firm Good, models exactly that: relationship conflict moderates the outcomes of task and process conflict. The same argument about a pricing decision produces a better decision in a family that’s fine and a worse one in a family that isn’t. De Massis names the crossover directly, personal tensions “may be brought into the business due to communication dynamics among family members,” and boardroom conflicts “reverberate at home or in other workplace settings.”

Here’s the tell, and you already know it. A task conflict ends when new information arrives. A relationship conflict doesn’t. If your brother concedes the number and is still angry, the number was never the subject. If the same two people fight about six unrelated things a year and land in the same emotional position every time, you have one conflict, not six.

Why Role Ambiguity Generates More of This Than Personality Does

Before you decide two people can’t work together, check whether anyone ever told them what they were each responsible for.

A company that hired its way to fifty people writes roles down, because strangers need instructions. A family company inherits them. Your sister runs operations because she was the one at home when the operations manager quit in 2014. Your father still signs off on equipment because he always has. Nobody wrote it down, because everybody knew.

Then two people’s authority overlaps on one decision, and what follows looks like a personality clash. It isn’t. It’s a design flaw with two people standing in it.

John A. Davis, who developed the three-circle model of the family business system at Harvard Business School, lists what family assemblies and councils are supposed to produce and the first item is to “Develop clarity on roles, rights, and responsibilities for family members.” Note that this sits in the governance column, not the therapy column. Harvard’s Program on Negotiation makes the same point from the other side: drawing on Roger Fisher and Daniel Shapiro’s work, it names role as one of five core concerns driving emotion in a negotiation, alongside appreciation, affiliation, autonomy and status. When a person’s role is unclear, what they feel isn’t confusion. It’s threat.

So before you book anybody: write down the three decisions each of you owns outright, and the three you’re required to make together. If two people claim the same decision, you’ve found your conflict, and it’s a document problem before it’s a relationship problem. This is the cheapest fix in this article, and I’d rather you tried it than paid me.

One caution about where that list comes from. If the reason nobody can write it down is that a founder still quietly decides everything regardless of what the chart says, the document will not survive its first week. That is a different problem with a different fix, and it has its own piece: When the Founder Can’t Let Go: Helping an Owner Step Back From Control.

The Escalation Path: Four Steps, In Order

Each step is cheaper, quieter and more reversible than the one after it, and each one you skip makes the next one harder.

Step 1: The direct private conversation. Two people, one issue, no audience, scheduled rather than ambushed. Say what you observed, what it cost, and what you want instead. Most conflicts that get called intractable have never had this conversation. They’ve had eleven versions of it in a hallway.

Step 2: The structured conversation. Same two people, now with an agenda, a time limit and ground rules agreed in advance. Writing for The Family Business Consulting Group, Penny Webb describes the facilitator’s job precisely: to help the family “face the specific issue at the heart of the conflict; to define the problem and separate it from other disagreements about which there may also be ill-feeling.” Her rule for those other disagreements is the one families never manage alone. “Other issues can be acknowledged, but we should move on and set them aside for another time.” Her other ground rules: treat the other person’s feelings as valid even where you disagree, ban personal criticism, put a clock on it. And her warning, which is why step 2 exists at all: unresolved and unspoken conflict “is a pressure cooker and the avoidance of debate…jams the safety valve closed.”

Step 3: A standing forum, so this stops being ad hoc. This is what a family meeting is for. Davis describes three components of family governance: periodic family assemblies including all adult family members, family council meetings run by a smaller representative group, and a family constitution setting out written policies and values. Size decides which you need. “If your family has fifteen or fewer adults, you may be able to have in-depth discussions and create plans and policies in the family assembly meeting,” with a council becoming useful past that. A council is not a board: writing in Family Business Magazine, Jeremy Lurey notes councils “generally don’t take ‘ownership positions’ with regard to the business or any business decisions,” and that its charter should spell out which body decides what. And these meetings don’t open with the conflict. Barbara Dartt and Anne Hargrave describe a family whose first adult meeting covered “strengths, interests, skills and communication and learning styles,” with values and vision at the second.

Step 4: Write the escalation into policy before you need it. Carrie G. Hall, in Family Business Magazine, sets out the version I most often wish my clients had: a standing committee of five to seven trusted family members formed before any conflict erupts; regular polling of family members working in the business so the committee can “get a sense of trouble brewing”; a cooling-off period on non-urgent matters; then committee mediation, an objective outside facilitator, full-committee adjudication and, last, “binding arbitration before lawyers become involved.”

Read that last clause twice. The point of the whole ladder is to exhaust every private option before the dispute acquires a docket number.

Which Third Party; Coach, Mediator, Therapist or Lawyer?

These four get recommended interchangeably and they are not interchangeable.

Family business coach Mediator Marriage and family therapist Attorney
Question it answers “Can these people lead this company together?” “Can we settle this dispute without a court?” “Is something in this family’s functioning making people unwell?” “What are our rights and what do the documents say?”
What they do Work the relationships underneath the structure Facilitate communication and negotiation; per the Model Standards, promote “voluntary decision making by the parties to the dispute” Per the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, “diagnose and treat cognitive, behavioral, or similar disorders in the context of couples and other relationships” Advise on agreements, ownership and exposure
Do they decide anything No No. Bernard Kliska: “Unlike an arbitrator, a mediator does not mandate a settlement” No No, but they’ll tell you what a court might
State license required No, coaching credentials are voluntary Not to practice privately. Michigan’s court roster requires an approved 40-hour training plus observed and supervised mediations Yes, the BLS states all states require licensure Yes
What you leave with A different conversation, and behavior that holds after it A written agreement, or a clear no A clinical relationship, usually ongoing Documents and options
Trigger to call them The issue is a role, a relationship or a stalled decision Positions have hardened and money or ownership is on the table Depression, addiction, estrangement, or a pattern that predates the business Anyone has said “attorney” out loud

The honest boundaries: a coach shouldn’t be doing therapy, a mediator isn’t there to fix your family, a therapist isn’t going to redraw your org chart, and none of the first three should be giving you legal advice. Anyone who claims all four columns has told you something useful about themselves.

The Part Most People Miss: Whether What Gets Said in That Room Can Be Repeated Later Depends on Which Person You Hired

Most articles stop at “bring in a neutral third party.” True, and not very useful, because the question nobody asks before the first session is the one that decides whether anyone in the room tells the truth.

Can what my brother says in here be used against him later?

The answer is different for each of those four columns, and it isn’t what people assume.

Start with the distinction, which the Supreme Court of Ohio states more clearly than anyone. Privilege “refers to what mediation communications may or may not be disclosed in subsequent legal proceedings after the mediation is over.” Confidentiality, by contrast, “is decided by the parties prior to the mediation and usually solidified in a contract.” Those are two different products, and most families buy the second believing they bought the first.

A statutory privilege exists in some places and not others. The Uniform Mediation Act was written, in Resolution Systems Institute’s words, to “create a uniform privilege for mediation communications in all of the United States, thus eliminating the high variability and inconsistency between various state rules.” It hasn’t achieved that. Connecticut became the thirteenth state to adopt it on October 1, 2025, joining Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa, Nebraska, New Jersey, Ohio, South Dakota, Utah, Vermont and Washington, plus the District of Columbia — roughly a quarter of the country. As one ADR practitioner summary puts it, “there is no uniform mediation confidentiality law applicable in all 50 states, nor is there a uniform federal mediation confidentiality statute,” and some states “provide confidentiality only for mediations connected to a court proceeding and not to ‘private’ pre-suit mediations.”

Michigan, where I practice, is in that second group. It has not adopted the Uniform Mediation Act. What it has is a court rule, MCR 2.412, and the rule itself is strong: “Mediation communications are confidential. They are not subject to discovery, are not admissible in a proceeding, and may not be disclosed to anyone other than mediation participants except as provided in subrule (D).” But by its own scope provision, that rule applies to cases the court has referred to mediation. Nobody has referred your family’s argument to anything. There is no case, which is the entire point of what you are trying to do.

Compare the other rooms. A licensed therapist’s is protected: in Jaffee v. Redmond (1996) the US Supreme Court held that “the conversations between Redmond and her therapist and the notes taken during their counseling sessions are protected from compelled disclosure under Rule 501,” extending that privilege to licensed social workers doing psychotherapy. A lawyer’s room runs on its own rules — ask them directly, and ask specifically who their client is, because in a company it is usually the entity rather than any of you.

And a coach’s room, mine, has no statutory privilege at all. What protects a facilitated family conversation with me is a confidentiality clause in an engagement letter. That’s a contract between us. It is precisely what the Ohio court calls confidentiality rather than privilege, and I’d rather you knew that before the first session than after a subpoena.

Confidentiality is a promise. Privilege is a wall. Most families find out which one they bought at the worst possible moment.

What to do with that. If ownership, a buyout or real money is in play, use a mediator and sign the confidentiality terms into a record before the first session; note how Washington’s enactment of the UMA defines its own reach: it applies where “the mediation parties and the mediator agree to mediate in a record that demonstrates an expectation that mediation communications will be privileged against disclosure.” In a UMA state the document switches the protection on; everywhere else a signed mediation agreement is still the strongest instrument you have. If the conflict is about roles, respect and whether these people can lead together, a coach is the right room, and the low legal stakes are exactly why it works. Nothing is being preserved for a proceeding, so people can say the true thing. Either way, decide which room you’re in and tell everyone before anybody speaks. The worst outcome is a family that opened up in a room they believed was sealed.

Seven Questions Before You Bring Anyone In

Answer these honestly. Nobody’s watching.

  1. When this last came up, did new information change anything, or did the same two people end in the same place?
  2. Can you write down right now the three decisions each person owns outright and the three you make together, without arguing about the list?
  3. Has anyone actually had the direct private conversation, scheduled and uninterrupted, or only versions of it in a hallway?
  4. Is there a standing forum where family issues are supposed to be raised, that met at least twice last year?
  5. Would the person you’re in conflict with agree, out loud, that a conflict exists?
  6. Is anyone’s ownership, buyout or compensation on the table in this dispute?
  7. Has anyone used the word “attorney” yet?

How to read it. A no on 2 or 3 means stop, you haven’t tried the free options, and no facilitator substitutes for a conversation nobody has attempted. A yes on 1 plus a yes on 5 is a relationship conflict with two willing people: coaching or facilitation territory, and usually resolvable. A yes on 6 or 7 means bring in a mediator and your attorney, sign the confidentiality terms in advance, and treat this as a dispute rather than a difficulty. A no on 5 is its own situation, and it’s next.

What If One Person Won’t Take Part?

There’s no technique that makes this go away. Mediation is defined by the Model Standards of Conduct for Mediators, adopted by the American Arbitration Association, the American Bar Association and the Association for Conflict Resolution in 2005, as a process that “promotes voluntary decision making by the parties to the dispute,” and the document’s first standard is that “a mediator shall conduct a mediation based on the principle of party self-determination.” You cannot compel someone into a voluntary process. Anyone who says otherwise is selling something.

What you can do:

  • Work your own side of it. One-to-one coaching for the willing person isn’t a consolation prize. Conflict is a system with two inputs, and changing one changes the pattern more often than people expect.
  • Change the structure instead of the person. Written roles, a defined decision list and a scheduled forum reduce the number of collisions available. Kliska’s account of a family business mediation contains the line that should worry you: “The unwillingness to communicate about this issue became a refusal to communicate about other management issues.” Refusal spreads. Structure limits the surface it can spread across.
  • Lower the ask. “Sit down with a coach and work through fifteen years” is a large request. “Ninety minutes, one agenda item, and you can leave” is a small one. People refuse the frame far more often than they refuse the conversation.
  • Write the requirement into the documents for next time. Hall’s ladder ends with arbitration “before lawyers become involved” for a reason. A dispute-resolution clause agreed while everyone is calm is how a family pre-commits its future self to a process nobody volunteers for in the moment.
  • Accept that it may be a boundary rather than a tactic. Some people decline because what you’re asking is genuinely beyond what they can do right now — which is itself information about which column you need.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

How do I tell a business disagreement from a family argument in the moment?

Ask what would have to be true for this to be settled. If the answer is a number, a date or a piece of information, it’s a task conflict and it will end. If you can’t name any fact that would end it, or if the answer includes the word “finally”, it’s a relationship conflict wearing business clothes, and arguing about the number will only make you both better at it.

Should we do this at a family meeting or a business meeting?

Different rooms, labeled out loud. Business decisions belong in the leadership meeting with the non-family people accountable for them. Family issues; expectations, fairness, who’s in and who’s out, belong in a family forum, which Davis treats as a distinct governance component from the board. The failure mode is a family issue raised in a business meeting, where your non-family managers have to sit through it and learn something about your family they can’t unlearn.

We’re two siblings and one owner. Do we really need a “council”?

Almost certainly not. Davis’s threshold is fifteen adults; below that an assembly-style family meeting is usually enough. What you need is a recurring conversation with an agenda and a rule about what gets discussed where. Calling it a council when there are three of you is theater, and your family will treat it as theater.

Isn’t bringing in an outsider an escalation in itself?

It can be, if it arrives as a surprise or as a verdict. It isn’t, if both people agree to it in advance and both understand what the person is and is not there to do. Keep the scope narrow, one issue, a set number of sessions, a named outcome, rather than opening the whole family for review.

What about the ownership question underneath all of this?

A different set of professionals, and a different conversation. What I’ll say here is that a conflict which keeps returning to “who will own this” won’t be resolved by better meetings, you are arguing about a design decision nobody has made yet, and no amount of ground rules will make it. Start with Fair vs. Equal: Dividing Ownership and Roles Among Your Children, which is about separating the money, the votes and the job instead of splitting all three the same way. If the recurring fight is instead about a relative who was hired without anyone agreeing the seat should exist, that one is How to Bring a Spouse, Sibling, or In-Law Into the Business Fairly.

Where I Fit, and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct with you, because that’s what I’d want.

If money, ownership or a buyout is on the table and positions have hardened, what you need is a mediator with a signed confidentiality agreement and your attorney on call. I’m not that person, and I’ll tell you so on the call rather than after the invoice. If what’s going on is depression, addiction or an estrangement that predates the business, you need a licensed clinician, and I’ll say that too. And if the honest answer is that nobody ever wrote down who decides what, that’s a document you can produce this month for nothing.

Here’s where I do fit:

  • Credentials in the underlying discipline. MHRLR, a master’s degree from Michigan State University, described by the practice as one of the top human resource programs in the country — and SPHR, the Senior Professional in Human Resources certification.
  • Thirty years in the relationship layer. More than 30 years with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits. Family business strategy is a stated core specialty, including “the unique dynamics present in family businesses.”
  • Conflict is a named service, not a sideline. Communication consulting and conflict resolution, and facilitated difficult conversations, with stated outcomes including “Better understanding of the issues” and “Commitments to each other for the future.”
  • A method for finding out what’s actually going on. Team assessments begin with an interview-style survey of employees in a space where they can speak openly, and end in a Report of Findings pairing each identified issue with a prescribed action. When a family disagrees about whether there’s a problem, that document tends to end the argument.
  • Third-party endorsement. Gino Wickman, creator of EOS and author of Traction and Get A Grip: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.” And Nick Tonkin, Director of Corporate Wellness, on the same page: “Kirsten has helped resolve many interoffice conflicts and tensions… The office runs smooth and more work gets done.”
  • On the record, and referred in. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s. EOS Implementers refer more work to my practice than any other source, not because their tools failed, but because the tools worked and surfaced something outside the toolbox.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call. It’s a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what’s really going on in your business or leadership. If the answer is that you need a mediator, a lawyer or a therapist instead of me, I’ll say so. If the answer is a written role list and a recurring meeting, I’ll say that too, and it will cost you nothing.

You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams. Sessions run via Zoom or in person in New Hudson, Michigan. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on claims: the statement that EOS Implementers refer more work to Focus Forward Coaching than any other source is my own account of my practice, not independently published data. Nothing here is legal advice; the confidentiality and privilege rules described are Michigan’s and the named states’, and yours may differ, so ask your own attorney before relying on any of it. Every other figure, quotation and rule cited is sourced below.

Sources

All URLs accessed August 13, 2026.

Conflict research

Family governance and conflict process

Mediation standards, privilege and licensure

Focus Forward Coaching

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights