Family business and leadership coaching for owners, successors, and teams running on EOS

Focus Forward · Leadership

Getting the Right People in the Right Seats When the People Are Family: Start With the Seat, Not the Person

The academic evidence on family successors is worse than you would like. It also points at how the person was chosen rather than at who they are related to — and that is the part you can actually fix.

Last updated: 13 August 2026

By Kirsten Ross Vogel, MLIR, SPHR — Focus Forward Coaching, New Hudson, Michigan. Leadership and family business coach; not an EOS Implementer.

You fix this by defining the seat before you look at the person, and never in the other order. A seat is a set of named responsibilities with a measure attached to it — not a title, and not a description of whoever happens to be sitting there. In most family companies at least one seat was built backwards: somebody needed a place, so a place appeared, and the structure became a record of who arrived when rather than what the business needs. That is fixable without telling anyone they are not good enough, because the honest version of the problem was never about capability. It is about how the seat got filled — which is also, uncomfortably, what the research on family successors points at.

First, What Is a Seat, and How Is It Different From a Title?

A title is what people call you. A seat is what you are accountable for, and how anybody knows whether it happened.

The clearest published definition comes from EOS, and it is worth borrowing whether or not you run on the system. EOS Worldwide’s glossary describes the Accountability Chart as “the right structure of seats (roles), with the right people in them, to achieve the vision,” and then adds the sentence that does all the work: “Structure comes first; people fill the seats.” On its own page for the tool, EOS says the chart “defines the right structure for your company, independent of the people who fill the seats today,” and that “each seat is accountable for five to seven major roles.” Its test for whether a person belongs in a seat is GWC — do they Get it, Want it, and have the Capacity to do it, with all three required to be yes.

You do not have to adopt EOS to use that distinction. You do have to be able to answer three questions about every box on your chart.

  • What is this seat accountable for? Five to seven things, written down, in language a new hire could read.
  • What is the one number that says it is being done? Not a feeling about the person. A number that existed before the disagreement did.
  • Who owns it — one name? Two names on one accountability is not shared ownership. It is an argument with a start date.

Writing it down is not bureaucracy; it is the thing that converts an understanding into an obligation. The family business practice at Davis Wright Tremaine puts it plainly: “taking the time to define the role and write it out takes that a step farther and creates accountability.”

Why the Structure Drifts in a Family Company

Because in a family company, people arrive whether or not there is an opening.

Family Enterprise USA’s 2025 Annual Family Business Survey — 730 respondents across 45 states, fielded in January and February 2025 — reports that 66.6% of next-generation family members work in the family business. That is not a scandal. It is the normal condition of the companies I work with, and it is exactly the condition under which seats get built around people.

The sequence is always the same and nobody notices it happening. A son finishes school in a soft year. A daughter’s marriage ends and she needs steady income. A brother-in-law’s employer closes. Each time, a place is found. Ten years later the chart has a box called “Special Projects,” a box called “Operations Support,” and a VP of something nobody outside the family can define — and every one of those boxes is a person’s name written in a different font.

Here is the difference, laid out honestly.

A seat built around the work A seat built around a person
Where it starts With a gap in the business With a person who needs a place
What gets written first The responsibilities and the measure The title
What happens if that person leaves The seat stays and you hire for it The seat quietly disappears, and nothing breaks
Who it can be compared against Anyone in the market who could do the work Nobody. There is no outside benchmark, by design
What the pay is based on The market rate for the job Need, parity between siblings, or history
How you know it is working The number Whether anyone has complained lately
What it teaches your non-family staff That the ladder is real all the way up That the ladder stops just below a certain last name
What it costs to change A hiring decision A family decision, at a family price

The fourth row is the one to sit with. A seat nobody outside your family could have applied for is a seat nobody outside your family can be measured against — and that is the whole difficulty in one line. It is also why “he’s not good enough” is the wrong sentence. Nobody has established what good enough would be.

What Has to Be True Before a Family Member Takes a Seat

These are entry conditions, and they are far easier to set before the person arrives than to impose afterward. Most family businesses write them one generation too late.

  • A real opening. The work exists whether or not this person does. A sample family employment policy published by Family Business Magazine handles the exception without pretending it away: family members “will be considered for available positions within the Company for which they have the required skills and abilities to successfully fulfill the role,” and “it is possible a position may be created for a family member if there is deemed to be value and need.” Note the standard — value and need, decided in advance and out loud, not a job discovered in a hurry on a Sunday.
  • A job description that existed before the candidate did. If the description was written after you knew who was taking it, it is a portrait, not a specification. You will not be able to hold anyone to a portrait.
  • Qualifications set in advance. The same sample policy sets a minimum of three years of full-time work experience elsewhere and a four-year degree for anyone on a management track. Steven Staugaitis of Kreischer Miller, writing on family employment policies, suggests two to five years of outside work experience as an ideal. Whatever you choose, choose it before the name is known.
  • A manager who is not their parent. This one is mine rather than a published finding, but thirty years in these rooms has not produced a counterexample. A parent cannot give a clean performance review to their own child, and a child cannot hear one.
  • A door that is described honestly. Say out loud what happens if it does not work — and say it while everyone is still hopeful, because that is the only moment anyone will agree to it.

One caution on that outside-experience rule, because it is repeated everywhere as settled fact and it is not. Joseph Astrachan, Isabel Botero and Carol Wittmeyer studied 37 people across 11 successful US family businesses in their third generation or later, and reported in Family Business Magazine in March 2024 that outside work experience, “while preferred by a majority of advisers… is definitely not necessary for the next generation to succeed.” What mattered instead was “the family’s ability to have open conversations as well as the individual’s motivation and talents.” Their point is not that outside experience is worthless. It is that the thing outside experience is supposed to build — credibility, judgment, a standard to be measured against — can be built other ways, and if you install the rule and skip the substance you have bought a delay, not a leader.

The Uncomfortable Part: The Evidence Is About the Shortlist, Not the Bloodline

Most articles on this topic stop at “hire for the role, not the relationship.” True, and not very useful to you when the person in front of you is your daughter and the role is one she has been doing for six years.

So here is the research almost nobody in this field puts in front of an owner, including the part that does not flatter anyone.

Francisco Pérez-González, in the American Economic Review in 2006, studied CEO successions and found that “firms where incoming CEOs are related to the departing CEO, to a founder, or to a large shareholder by either blood or marriage underperform in terms of operating profitability and market-to-book ratios, relative to firms that promote unrelated CEOs.”

Read the next sentence of that abstract slowly, because it is the hinge of this entire article: “Consistent with wasteful nepotism, lower performance is prominent in firms that appoint family CEOs who did not attend ‘selective’ undergraduate institutions.” And his conclusion: “the evidence indicates that nepotism hurts performance by limiting the scope of labor market competition.”

That is not a finding about family. It is a finding about the size of the pool the choice was made from.

The causal version came a year later. Morten Bennedsen, Kasper Nielsen, Francisco Pérez-González and Daniel Wolfenzon, in the Quarterly Journal of Economics in 2007, used Danish data and an unusual trick: the gender of the departing CEO’s firstborn child. Firms whose owner had a first-born son were more likely to hand the company to a family member, and the gender of somebody’s first child is not otherwise connected to how the business performs — which lets you separate the effect of the succession decision from the kind of firm that makes it. Their finding: “family successions have a large negative causal impact on firm performance: operating profitability on assets falls by at least four percentage points around CEO transitions.” The damage was largest “in fast-growing industries, industries with highly skilled labor force, and relatively large firms.”

Now the other side, because it exists and it is just as serious. Ronald Anderson and David Reeb, in the Journal of Finance in 2003, looked at the S&P 500 and found the opposite of what they expected: “Contrary to our conjecture, we find family firms perform better than nonfamily firms,” and “when family members serve as CEO, performance is better than with outside CEOs.”

The two literatures look irreconcilable until you look at which family members. Belén Villalonga and Raphael Amit, in the Journal of Financial Economics in 2006, ran the split on Fortune 500 firms from 1994 to 2000: “family ownership creates value only when the founder serves as CEO of the family firm or as Chairman with a hired CEO… When descendants serve as CEOs, firm value is destroyed.”

Put the four together and the picture is not “family bad.” It is narrower and much more useful than that. Family ownership is not the risk. Family control is not the risk. The risk sits at one specific moment — the moment a seat gets filled from a list of people who share a surname, without anyone ever establishing what the seat required or who else could have done it. Pérez-González’s own explanation is the shortlist, not the gene pool. Morten Bennedsen, writing later for INSEAD with Claire Harbour and Antoine Tirard, said the practical version of it: “there is no absolute correlation between being a family member and being able to make a sound contribution to the business.”

Which is genuinely good news, and it is the reason this article is a how-to rather than a warning. A capability problem would be nobody’s fault and nobody’s fix. A selection problem is a process, and processes can be rebuilt on a Tuesday.

The evidence isn’t against your family. It’s against a shortlist of one.

When a Good Person Is in the Wrong Seat and There Is No Right One

This is the case owners actually get stuck on, and it deserves an honest answer rather than a reshuffle. Sometimes the person is capable, decent, hard-working and loyal, and there is simply no seat in your building where they would be the best available choice. Pretending otherwise is not kindness; everybody in the company can already see it.

Four real options, in descending order of how often they work:

  • Split the seat, not the person. A common version of “wrong seat” is a right person whose seat grew past them while they were busy doing it. The company doubled; the job became two jobs; they are failing at the half they were never good at and quietly excellent at the other half. Divide the accountabilities, give them the half they own, and hire the other half. This is not a demotion, and it will not read as one if the number moves.
  • Build a seat around real work — and test it. There is a legitimate version of building a role around a person: when they are genuinely better than anyone available at work the company actually needs done. The test is one question, asked coldly. If this person left, would you hire someone else into this seat? If the answer is yes, it is a real seat. If the answer is “no, we’d just absorb it,” you have written a job description for a salary.
  • Ownership without a job. Being an owner and being an employee are two different relationships with the company, and a family member can hold one without the other. This is the option nobody raises, and it is often the true answer.
  • Somewhere else, on good terms and with a real reason. Not a nudge toward the door dressed up as development. A described role in another company, a stated purpose, and honesty about whether there is a way back.

I have written separately about the difference between a family member who is underperforming and one whose behavior is the problem. This section assumes you have already worked out which of those you are looking at, because none of the four options above will do anything at all for the second one.

The Knot Behind “We Can’t Move Him”: Owner Pay and Employee Pay

Nine times out of ten, when an owner tells me a seat cannot be changed, the obstacle is not the org chart. It is the paycheck.

Kate Barnwell and Stephanie Brun de Pontet of The Family Business Consulting Group name it directly: “Over time, it becomes important not to conflate the rewards of ownership (returns you should expect because you keep your capital in the business) and those earned as a salary for doing a job.” When those two are blended into one number, they write, “not differentiating between these leads to distortions and potential resentments.”

Here is how that plays out in a real conversation. Your brother owns a third of the company and draws $180,000 as VP of Operations. Everyone agrees the operations seat needs someone else. Nobody will say so, because moving him out of the title cuts his income by $180,000 — and that is not a personnel decision, that is a decision about whether your brother’s family keeps their house.

Separate the two lines and the knot loosens. What does the operations seat pay at market? What return does a one-third owner receive on their capital? Those are different questions with different answers, and once they are on two lines instead of one, the seat becomes a job again. You can discuss a job. Almost nobody can discuss a job that is secretly also an inheritance.

You will not enjoy this conversation, and it usually needs your accountant in the room. It is still shorter than the ten years most families spend not having it.

A Test You Can Run Against Your Own Org Chart Tonight

Answer these honestly. Nobody is watching, and nothing here has to leave your desk. Print the chart first — this only works on paper.

  1. Cover every name. Reading only the boxes, can you tell what each seat is accountable for? Circle the ones you cannot.
  2. Name one number per seat. Write the single measure that tells you whether that seat is being done well. How many boxes end up blank?
  3. Kill each box in turn. If the person in it left on Friday, would you replace them — or would the work quietly get absorbed and never be mentioned again? Mark the ones that would disappear.
  4. Write the ad. For each family member’s seat, write the job posting you would run if you had to fill it from outside this week. Which ones can you not write without describing a specific human being?
  5. Run the shortlist. For your highest-paid family seat, imagine a proper outside search. Would the person currently in it make your final three? Not win — make the list.
  6. Split the money. Next to each family member’s name, write two figures: what the job pays, and what they receive as an owner. Can you produce both numbers, or is there only one?
  7. Find the double seat. Is there any accountability with two names on it because you could not decide? Name it.

How to read it. If you got through all seven with clean answers, your structure is in better shape than most and you do not need me — you need a quarterly discipline for keeping it that way. Circles on 1 and blanks on 2 are a documentation problem, and it is the cheapest of all these to fix; a weekend and a template will do it. Marks on 3 and 4 mean at least one seat is a person rather than a job, and until that is said out loud, every performance conversation in the building is being had in a language nobody agrees on. If 5 made you look away from the page, that is not a verdict on anyone’s character — reread the research section, because it is the most fixable finding on this list. And if 6 produced only one number, start there. That single number is the reason nothing else on your chart can move.

Questions Leaders Ask Me About This

Isn’t it insulting to make my own son apply for a job?

Less insulting than the alternative, which is a thirty-year career in which nobody can tell him whether he is any good. A defined seat with a number is the only thing that ever lets a family member own their success — right now, every result he gets is credited to his last name by somebody in your building, and he knows it. The application is not a test of his worth. It is the only way he gets to stop being on trial forever.

What if there genuinely isn’t anyone else who could do this job?

Then say so out loud and check it, because that sentence is true far less often than it feels. Write the job description, get one market salary benchmark, and ask one person outside the family whether they know anyone who could do it. If the answer really is no, you have not made a nepotism decision — you have made the only decision available, and you should record why, so that in five years it can be reviewed as a decision instead of defended as a tradition.

Do my kids really have to work somewhere else first?

Not necessarily, and the confident version of that advice is not backed by the research. Astrachan, Botero and Wittmeyer found that outside experience, though preferred by most advisers, was not necessary for next-generation success in the family businesses they studied. What the outside job is meant to supply — credibility, a standard, judgment formed where the surname meant nothing — still has to come from somewhere. If they join straight from school, you have to build all three deliberately inside the company, and most families do not.

We are 22 people. Do we need an org chart at all?

You have one. Everyone in the building could draw it, and their versions would disagree — which is the actual cost. At 22 people the document takes an afternoon, and its value is not the boxes. It is discovering, while drawing it, the two accountabilities nobody owns and the one that two people both think is theirs.

What if two of my children both want the same seat?

Then you have a decision to make and no article can make it for you. What I would not do is invent a second seat to avoid choosing — co-CEO structures created to spare a family the choice tend to postpone the conflict at compound interest, and your employees will work out within a month which one to actually ask. Define the seat first, in writing, before either of them is discussed by name. Some of these resolve themselves the moment the requirements are on paper, because one of the two reads the list and realizes they never wanted that job.

Where I Fit — and Where I Do Not

Let me be direct with you, because that is what I would want. I am not going to tell you which of your children should run this company. I have been asked to, more than once, and the answer is always the same: an outsider who has known your family for six weeks has no standing to make that call, and any advisor who accepts it has sold you a decision instead of helping you make one. What I will do is make sure the decision gets made by the people it belongs to, on the basis of something other than birth order and who is in the room. That is a different job, and it is the harder one.

  • The credentials behind the work. MLIR from Michigan State University and SPHR certification through HRCI — a background in human resources and labor relations, which is where seats, standards and compensation structures actually live.
  • More than 30 years in the relationship layer. Working with leaders in privately held companies, family businesses and non-profits, and running my own practice for more than 25 years. The specialism is family dynamics and the transition from one generation to the next.
  • EOS-fluent, not EOS-affiliated. I am not an EOS Implementer and I do not sell the system. I have coached leaders and teams running on EOS for more than 25 years, so if your Accountability Chart is the thing that started this argument, nobody has to stop and explain it to me.
  • Endorsed by the man who built EOS. Gino Wickman, creator of EOS and author of Traction and Get A Grip: “I cannot say enough about the wonderful work she has done with my clients. I get unsolicited rave reviews.”
  • How the work is actually done. Team assessments built on an interview-style survey in a safe space where people will say what is really happening, producing a Report of Findings that pairs every issue with a prescribed action — a customized roadmap. Facilitated difficult conversations. Conflict resolution. Business transition and transfer planning. Group coaching for up to eight. Individual leadership development in three steps: Awareness, Motivation, Change.
  • On the record. Author of Defeat Team Drama Now! and From People Problems to Productivity; featured as an expert by NBC Nightly News, Fox 2 News, National Public Radio, Entrepreneur, Working Mother and Crain’s.
  • Sent here by Implementers. EOS Implementers refer more work to me than any other source. They are very good at what they do. This is simply the part that is not theirs to do.

Where to Start

Schedule a Discovery Call. It is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation about what is really going on in your business. If what you need is an Implementer to build the structure, I will say so. If what you need is an afternoon with a whiteboard and no coach at all, I will say that too, on the call rather than after the invoice.

You are closer than you realize to the business and team of your dreams.

Sessions run via Zoom or in person at 30773 Milford Rd., Suite 121, New Hudson, Michigan. Call 248-973-7595.

A note on two claims: the statement that EOS Implementers refer more work to Focus Forward Coaching than any other source is Kirsten’s own account of her practice, not independently published data. The recommendation that a family member should not report to their own parent is her professional judgment from thirty years of practice, not a published research finding, and is flagged as such in the text. Every other figure and quotation in this article is sourced below. Nothing here is legal, tax or compensation advice.

Sources

All URLs accessed 13 August 2026.

Academic research on family succession and firm performance

Francisco Pérez-González, “Inherited Control and Firm Performance,” American Economic Review, vol. 96, no. 5 (December 2006), pp. 1559–1588 — abstract via the American Economic Association (underperformance of related-CEO successions; the “selective” undergraduate institution finding; nepotism limiting the scope of labor market competition) — https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.96.5.1559

Same paper, abstract reproduced on IDEAS/RePEc (used to corroborate the abstract wording quoted above) — https://ideas.repec.org/a/aea/aecrev/v96y2006i5p1559-1588.html

Morten Bennedsen, Kasper Meisner Nielsen, Francisco Pérez-González and Daniel Wolfenzon, “Inside the Family Firm: The Role of Families in Succession Decisions and Performance,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 122, no. 2 (2007), pp. 647–691 — abstract via IDEAS/RePEc (the firstborn-gender instrument; “operating profitability on assets falls by at least four percentage points”; where underperformance is largest) — https://ideas.repec.org/a/oup/qjecon/v122y2007i2p647-691..html

Same paper, NBER Working Paper 12356 (used to corroborate the abstract wording) — https://www.nber.org/papers/w12356

Ronald C. Anderson and David M. Reeb, “Founding-Family Ownership and Firm Performance: Evidence from the S&P 500,” Journal of Finance, vol. 58, no. 3 (2003), pp. 1301–1328 — abstract via IDEAS/RePEc (family firms outperforming non-family firms; family CEOs outperforming outside CEOs) — https://ideas.repec.org/a/bla/jfinan/v58y2003i3p1301-1328.html

Belén Villalonga and Raphael Amit, “How Do Family Ownership, Control and Management Affect Firm Value?”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 80, no. 2 (2006), pp. 385–417 — abstract via the University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons repository (Fortune 500, 1994–2000; founder-CEO value creation; “When descendants serve as CEOs, firm value is destroyed”) — https://repository.upenn.edu/mgmt_papers/155/

Morten Bennedsen, Claire Harbour and Antoine Tirard, “A Career in the Family Business: Duty or Choice?”, INSEAD Knowledge, 4 January 2023 (“there is no absolute correlation between being a family member and being able to make a sound contribution to the business”) — https://knowledge.insead.edu/family-business/career-family-business-duty-or-choice

Family business practice and survey data

Family Enterprise USA, 2025 Annual Family Business Survey, executive summary (730 respondents across 45 states, fielded January–February 2025; 66.6% of next-generation family members working in the family business) — https://familyenterpriseusa.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/2025.FEUSA-Survey.-Executive-Summary.Final_.v.2.1.pdf

Joseph H. Astrachan, Isabel C. Botero and Carol B. Wittmeyer, “Do family business NextGens need outside work experience?”, Family Business Magazine, 9 March 2024 (37 individuals across 11 US family businesses in the third generation or later; outside experience “definitely not necessary”) — https://familybusinessmagazine.com/engagement/nextgens/do-family-business-nextgens-need-outside-work-experience/

Sample Family Employment Policy published by Family Business Magazine (three years of outside full-time work experience; four-year degree for the management track; positions created only where there is “value and need”) — https://familybusinessmagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/2-FamilyEmploymentPolicy.pdf

Steven E. Staugaitis, “Five Key Aspects of a Successful Family Employment Policy,” Kreischer Miller, 12 March 2014 (two to five years of outside work experience as an ideal; the five sections of a family employment policy) — https://www.kmco.com/insights/five-key-aspects-of-a-successful-family-employment-policy/

Kate Barnwell and Stephanie Brun de Pontet, “Paying Family in a Family Business: Where Good Intentions Create Hidden Risks,” The Family Business Consulting Group, 1 April 2026 (not conflating the rewards of ownership with salary for doing a job) — https://www.thefbcg.com/resource/paying-family-in-a-family-business-where-good-intentions-create-hidden-risks/

Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, “Defining and Documenting Roles in a Family Business,” Family Business Resource Center, 9 February 2021 (writing the role down creates accountability) — https://www.dwt.com/blogs/family-business-resource-center/2021/02/defining-roles-in-a-family-business

EOS terminology

EOS Worldwide, EOS Glossary (Accountability Chart; “Structure comes first; people fill the seats”; GWC; Right Person, Right Seat) — https://www.eosworldwide.com/glossary

EOS Worldwide, “What is an Accountability Chart?” (structure defined independently of the people currently in the seats; five to seven major roles per seat) — https://www.eosworldwide.com/accountability-chart

Focus Forward Coaching

About Kirsten Ross Vogel (MLIR, SPHR, more than 30 years, practice launched more than 25 years ago, books, media features) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/about/

Coaching and services (team assessment and Report of Findings, family business strategy, transition and transfer planning, groups of up to eight, Awareness–Motivation–Change) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/services/

Testimonials, including the Gino Wickman endorsement quoted above — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/testimonials/

FAQ (Discovery Call, Zoom or the New Hudson office, address and phone number) — https://focusforwardcoaching.com/faq/

Need help with a conversation carrying real stakes?

Kirsten can help you prepare the message, facilitate the discussion, or address the deeper pattern behind recurring conflict.

Keep reading

Related insights